Analysis · Mario Kart 8

Mario Kart 8 turns walls and ceilings into racing lines, and bumps into boosts

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Driving upside down is the whole pitch

Mario Kart 8 keeps the series formula: Nintendo characters race go-karts around themed tracks and grab power-ups from item boxes. Its signature addition is anti-gravity racing. On certain stretches of a course, racers drive up walls and across ceilings.

The more interesting part is the rule that comes with it. In anti-gravity sections, colliding with another racer or a special bumper gives you a speed boost. In most kart racers, contact costs you. Here, in those stretches, it pays. That one change asks you to drive toward the pack instead of away from it, and it gives the familiar formula a new decision to make on every lap.

The question for everything else in the game is simple: does it back up a racer that rewards getting close?

The new items punish and protect at close range

The four new items mostly fit the theme. Three of them work best when other racers are near:

  • Boomerang Flower: throws boomerangs that hit other racers.
  • Piranha Plant: bites nearby racers and obstacles, and gives a speed boost.
  • Super Horn: blasts nearby opponents and blocks incoming items, including the Spiny Shell.
  • Crazy Eight: hands you eight different items at once.

The Super Horn is the most significant. The Spiny Shell had been nearly impossible to avoid, which made a race leader a sitting target. A defensive answer to it gives skilled players a way to protect a lead. The trade-off is that you can carry only one item at a time on Wii U, so holding a horn means passing up anything else.

Plenty of track, with a few gaps at launch

The base game has 32 courses across eight cups. Another 16 courses arrived later as downloadable content, in four more cups. Mario Kart 8 also brings back features from recent entries:

  • motorbikes and 12-racer fields, from Mario Kart Wii;
  • hang gliders, underwater racing and vehicle customization, from Mario Kart 7;
  • karts, motorbikes and all-terrain vehicles to choose from.

New faces include the Koopalings and Pink Gold Peach. Difficulty runs from 50cc to 150cc and Mirror Mode, which flips every course left to right. Higher classes make races faster. The fastest class, 200cc, wasn't there at launch and came in a later update. That matters for anti-gravity sections, since a speed-boost mechanic means more when the base speed is higher.

Made for a full couch or a full lobby

Up to four players can share one Wii U, and up to 12 can race online. Besides Grand Prix racing, there are arena-based battle modes. The game is rated Everyone and PEGI 3, so the whole household can play.

This is where the anti-gravity idea pays off most. A race against the computer rewards contact, but a race against friends makes every bump into a choice. You trade paint for speed with someone sitting next to you.

What critics' numbers say, and the Switch question

Critics were strongly positive. One aggregate puts the game at 88/100 across 79 reviews, and a smaller aggregate of 10 reviews lands at 83/100. The critic average of 8.6, computed from those critic aggregates, sits between them. The scores don't spell out which features critics liked best, so read them as broad approval, not praise for any one feature.

The bigger question for a new buyer is which version to get. Mario Kart 8 Deluxe for Nintendo Switch includes all the Wii U downloadable content, available from the start. It also adds characters such as the Inklings and King Boo, lets you hold two items at once, and brings back the Boo item. For newer players, it adds help like auto-acceleration and smart steering, which keeps you from veering off course. The Wii U original has none of those. If you have a Wii U, though, this is the version you can play, and it already has the anti-gravity racing at its core.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet