Mario Kart World's racing soars while its open world runs thin
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A series high, or a big world with little in it
The highest praise came from Destructoid, which said Mario Kart World "may be the best game" in the series. PCMag went further and called it "a generational leap forward" for Mario Kart. The sharpest criticism came from Yussef Cole in The New York Times. He found it "elegant, but mostly empty" and said its Free Roam mode can't compete with open-world racers like Forza Horizon or Burnout Paradise.
Both sides are describing the same game. The racing is polished, and the open world that ties the tracks together is thin. Most critics weighed the first point more heavily. On OpenCritic, 97% of critics recommended it, and all four Famitsu reviewers gave it 9 out of 10. Metacritic rated the reviews "generally favorable." the critic average, which is calculated from those critic aggregates, is 8.6 out of 10.
The racing is the part nobody argues about
IGN's Logan Plant praised the polished gameplay and controls, the new mechanics and a soundtrack he called "celebratory." The core formula hasn't changed: you race as Mario characters and use items to get ahead. What's new is the scale. Races hold up to 24 players, twice as many as Mario Kart 8 Deluxe. There are also amphibious vehicles and parkour-style moves that let karts go off the usual racing line.
The roster has 50 characters. Many of the ones that aren't playable show up on the tracks as obstacles. The Guardian's Keza MacDonald liked how "broad and ridiculous" the lineup is. Twenty-four of the characters have alternate costumes, which you earn by eating food items found during races. GameSpot praised the new features and called this game's version of Rainbow Road "an all-time great."
Knockout Tour is the new idea that landed
The new mode critics singled out most is Knockout Tour. It's one long race across the whole map with 24 racers. There are six checkpoints along the way, and the last four racers are eliminated at each one. IGN and Destructoid both named it as a highlight. It's also the mode that makes the best use of the connected world, because the trip across the map is the whole point.
Grand Prix works differently than in earlier games. Only the first race in a cup is a standard three-lap race. After that, you drive between courses on routes through the open world. If you want the classic format, VS mode still runs three-lap races, and Mirror Mode, which flips the whole map, is back. Battle Mode also returns, with Balloon Battle, Bob-omb Blast and Coin Runners.
Free Roam and the routes are where it stumbles
In Free Roam you can drive anywhere on the map except Rainbow Road. It has missions, a feature returning from Mario Kart DS, plus collectibles. Critics were lukewarm about it. IGN called it "uneven." Edge called the challenges "decent but unexceptional" and saw them mostly as driving practice, something to do while waiting for a friend to join an online lobby. Critics also pointed out that Free Roam has no local co-op, even though that feature had been reported to be in the game.
Opinions on the route courses that connect the tracks were mixed, especially in online play. The problem shows clearly in the game's update history:
- Before version 1.1.2, online lobbies tended to pick the "random" option, which meant traditional three-lap races on one of the 30 courses.
- Update 1.1.2 added the 202 route courses to that option, and routes started showing up far more often than full courses.
- Players pushed back hard, and the game was review-bombed on Metacritic.
- Update 1.3.0, released in September 2025, partly reversed the change and made new characters easier to earn.
IGN also criticized the limits on online multiplayer and some of the choices behind the interface and how rewards are earned. The 1.3.0 update eased some of the complaints about earning characters, but the route balance was only slightly adjusted. If you mostly play online, expect plenty of route driving between the full courses.
Where it sits for Switch 2 owners
Mario Kart World is a Switch 2 exclusive, and players have treated it as the console's main game. As of September 30, 2026, it is the best-selling Switch 2 game, at 16.48 million copies worldwide. It's rated Everyone and PEGI 3, so the whole family can play. The 24-player races and the large roster suit a crowded couch or a busy lobby.
Just don't count on the open world to carry the game. Critics who loved it loved the racing and Knockout Tour. Critics who were let down were mostly let down by everything in between.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Mario Kart World en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q131767872 wikidata.org