Analysis · Mario Party 10

Mario Party 10 lives or dies on whether your group wants to be Bowser

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Bowser Party drew both the loudest praise and the sharpest complaints

The biggest argument about Mario Party 10 is over its headline mode. In Bowser Party, four players form Team Mario. A fifth player plays Bowser on the Wii U GamePad, rolls four dice and chases the group down the board. Catching them starts one of 12 GamePad minigames built to wear Team Mario down.

Game Informer's Kyle Hilliard called it the best mode in the game because it leans on skill. IGN's Samuel Claiborn called the Bowser role "a blast" and rated the mode among the best uses of the GamePad up to that point.

Other critics saw the same mode differently. Destructoid's Chris Carter said the linear board usually let one side pull ahead on luck, so the two teams rarely touched. GameSpot's Mark Walton called Bowser the least fun seat because of all the waiting. Electronic Gaming Monthly's Ray Carsillo criticized its minigame variety and balance. Hardcore Gamer's Dermot Creegan agreed it was the best mode but called it "the most barren," with few boards and minigames.

The shared car is the other dividing line

The main Mario Party mode carries over the vehicle from Mario Party 9. All four players ride together, take turns as the operator who rolls the die, and race to collect the most mini-stars by the end of the board. Each board has two co-op boss battles, and a round runs about 30 minutes.

Critics disagreed sharply here too:

  • Against: Carter got used to the car but still found it dull next to moving on your own, since special spaces get skipped easily. He also wanted a way to set round length.
  • For: Hilliard liked how it sped up play. Nintendo Life's Martin Watts agreed and said it made play more tactical, since every move affects everyone.
  • In between: Carsillo didn't mind the co-op turn but said the game changed too little from Mario Party 9 and missed the cutthroat feel of older entries.

What nearly everyone liked

The praise was steadier on presentation and pace. Critics liked the shorter rounds and the high-definition graphics. Claiborn said split-screen was much easier to read because of the sharper image. Hilliard singled out the music, writing that even the plainest remixes of Koji Kondo's scores were "immensely enjoyable."

The 70-plus minigames got credit too. Free-for-alls, two-versus-two and three-versus-one games mix memory, puzzle and platform play. Carter liked that the controls went beyond the Wii Remote shaking that he said dominated Mario Party 8 and Mario Party 9.

The shared complaints were just as consistent. Carsillo and Hilliard both found the GamePad underused in the main mode. Several critics felt the game didn't move far enough from its predecessors.

Amiibo Party costs extra to enjoy fully

Amiibo Party went back to classic Mario Party rules, and critics liked it more on the whole. Carter liked that return but called the boards small. He also flagged that using every supported character means buying $100 worth of Amiibo figures. Hilliard enjoyed scanning a figure to move until the novelty wore off. Walton said Amiibo only change how the game looks, not how it plays, which leaves the mode close to the main one.

Reading the split for your own group

The disagreements follow a pattern. Critics who wanted faster, team-minded play leaned positive. Critics who wanted the old every-player-for-themselves board game leaned negative. That gap explains a Metacritic weighted average of 66/100 sitting next to an OpenCritic recommendation rate of just 16%. The critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 6.5 out of 10.

If your group regularly has five people and someone enjoys playing the villain, Bowser Party is the reason to own this. If you count four or fewer and prize long, scheming boards, the shared car and short rounds will likely feel like a step back.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet