Mario + Rabbids Kingdom Battle makes tactics easy to learn and hard to put down
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Award-winning battles, forgettable hallways
Critics liked the combat in Mario + Rabbids Kingdom Battle best. They were least impressed by the parts you walk through to reach it. Reviewers praised the turn-based battles for making tactics easy to pick up, and the game won "Best Strategy Game" at The Game Awards 2017, Gamescom and the Game Critics Awards. Destructoid's Chris Carter saw it differently. He called the space between levels filler that mostly exists to hide collectibles.
Both views are fair, but the battles count for much more than the hallways. OpenCritic reported that 92% of critics recommended the game, and Metacritic summed up its reviews as "generally favorable". The critic average, worked out from those critic aggregates, is 8.4 out of 10.
Many critics expected less. Several reviews opened by mocking the idea itself:
Giant Bomb called the concept a "bad, late-night message board conversation".
Once the game came out, many of those same critics admitted it had far more depth than they'd assumed.
Three actions a turn are enough
You pick three fighters from a cast of eight. Mario must be one of them, and at least one Rabbid has to come too. On each turn, every character can move, fire a weapon and use a special ability. Cover lowers how often enemies hit you. You can also dash into an enemy for damage, or bounce off a teammate to travel farther.
Weapons add side effects to the damage. A glob of honey stops an enemy from moving for a while. A burning shot sends the target running around in a panic. Specials include a heal for nearby allies and a hypnosis effect that pulls enemies toward the character who used it.
Critics agreed that keeping things simple was the right call:
- Polygon's Russ Frushstick said the game wasn't especially bold for older players, but it made the tactical role-playing genre inviting to people who had never tried it.
- PCMag credited the lack of dense statistics and probability math, and liked its simple "coin-flip" odds.
- The Verge said the short, structured battles suit the Switch's portable play.
- Several outlets compared it favorably to the XCOM series.
Rewards push you to play well. Each chapter usually has three levels and pays out coins and Skill Orbs. You earn more if you win within a set number of turns and keep the whole team alive. Skill Orbs go into each character's skill tree for new abilities, more health or longer movement, and coins buy new weapons.
The Rabbids turned out to be the surprise
Critics didn't expect the humor to work, and it mostly did. Wired's Julie Muncy noted that Mario often plays the straight man to the Rabbids' childish antics, and that contrast keeps the jokes from getting tiring.
Rabbid Peach got the most attention. Reactions were split before release, but critics warmed to her. Eurogamer's Chris Bratt first found her crass and came to enjoy her antics as more of the game was shown. Gabe Gurwin of Digital Trends called her the standout of the cast. Paul Tamburro of GameRevolution said she "steals the show".
The one sharp complaint was about the marketing, not the game. Kotaku's Gita Jackson found the social media campaign built around Rabbid Peach creepy, though she still thought the character was cute.
Exploring the worlds is where it sags
The campaign covers four worlds, and each one follows a linear path. Some puzzles block the way forward, while others pay out weapons and collectibles. Each finished world teaches your robot guide, Beep-0, a new ability for solving puzzles.
Reviewers had mixed feelings about this part. Destructoid saw it as padding. Game Informer's Jeff Marchiafava said collectibles such as music and concept art weren't worth the detour, though he felt the battles more than made up for it. GameSpot liked how the puzzles tie the setting together, and it called them a brief change of pace even when some got tedious.
One more catch: two weapons are only available if you connect certain Amiibo figurines. The rest of the arsenal comes from coins and progress.
The takeaway is simple. Rush through the overworld when you need to and spend your attention on the fights, which is what critics did.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Mario + Rabbids Kingdom Battle en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q30246427 wikidata.org