Analysis · Mario Sports Superstars

Mario Sports Superstars packs five full sports and drops the Mario chaos

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Five full sports, played by the rules

The game is built around five sports: association football, baseball, tennis, golf and horse racing. None of them are mini-games. Each one is a full version of its sport, and football shows how literally the game takes that. Matches are eleven versus eleven, the same as the real thing.

Tennis and golf borrow from earlier games in the series. On the court you get Chance Shots from Mario Tennis Open, plus Jump Shots and Ultra Smashes from Mario Tennis: Ultra Smash. Golf is based on Mario Golf: World Tour, and both sports reuse the look of those two games.

Critics mostly liked how the sports feel to play. Game Informer praised the core play of all five and said each is easy for players "of any skill level" to pick up. Pure Nintendo called them "five fun games". Few reviewers had trouble with the controls or the rules. Their complaints were about what was missing.

Why five games feel smaller than one

The biggest knock on the game is depth. Nintendo Life pointed out that the sports have been stripped of the power-ups, items and arcade-style modes that the standalone Mario sports games all had. Without them, a Mario tennis match plays a lot like plain tennis with familiar faces.

Several outlets described the same gap:

  • TheSixthAxis called the sports "lightweight or stripped back".
  • Nintendo Wire described them as five separate games with "minimal content".
  • Pure Nintendo said they lacked the depth of the standalone releases.
  • Nintendo Life said the whole package had less content than Mario Tennis: Ultra Smash, a game that was itself criticized for being thin.

Nintendo Life summed it up this way: the game "laid out the groundwork, but just needed to take a few more risks".

So you get variety across sports but not much inside any one of them. Nintendo Wire and Nintendo Life both said variety is the game's main strength, and it's also its limit. If you already own a standalone Mario tennis or golf game, this version gives you less of it.

Bright on screen, cynical about cards

TheSixthAxis praised the presentation as up to Nintendo's usual standard, calling it "bright, clear and welcoming". Building on the look of the earlier tennis and golf games gives those modes a polished base, and critics widely counted presentation as a strength.

The amiibo cards got the opposite reaction. Destructoid called the card feature a "lazy experience" made mainly to sell collectible cards. Critics broadly listed the cards among the game's main faults, and no outlet defended them.

Online is what keeps it going

Each sport comes with single-player tournaments, local multiplayer and online multiplayer. Critics found a clear gap between them. Nintendo Life said the game is at its best as a multiplayer title, especially online, and that climbing the online ranks could be fun. The same review called the single-player side "totally functional yet painfully lifeless".

That split shows up in the numbers too. Metacritic rated the game 60/100, which counts as mixed. OpenCritic was harsher: only 18% of critics recommended it. The critic average, worked out from those critic figures, is 6.0 out of 10.

The likely reason for that gap: most critics thought the game was decent but couldn't name a reason to choose it over the dedicated games. How long it lasts for you depends on whether you have people to play against. Solo, the tournaments run out of reasons to return fast.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet