Analysis · Mario Tennis Aces

Mario Tennis Aces wins its rallies and loses ground everywhere else

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Praise for the rallies, complaints about everything around them

The strongest praise came from IGN, which called Mario Tennis Aces "an extremely fun arcade tennis experience" and credited its smartly balanced back-and-forth play. The sharpest criticism was about everything off the court. IGN called the adventure mode underdeveloped and short on replay value, and both IGN and GameSpot said the main multiplayer modes lacked options.

That split shows up in the numbers. Metacritic's sample rated the game "generally favorable" with a 75/100, but OpenCritic counted only 56% of critics recommending it. Most critics liked what they played, but plenty stopped short of recommending it. The critic average sits at 7.6 out of 10.

The energy gauge turns every rally into a budget

The basics carry over from earlier games in the series: topspins that travel straight, slices that curve to one side and lobs that go high. Aces adds an energy gauge that fills as you keep a rally going, and most of the new moves spend it.

  • Zone shot: the game pauses so you can aim exactly where the ball goes. An opponent who returns it takes racket damage.
  • Zone speed: the match slows down while your character keeps moving at normal speed, so distant balls are easier to reach.
  • Trick shot: a quick dash to where the ball will land. It fills the gauge fast if it works, and it's easy to mistime.
  • Special shot: needs a full gauge and can break a racket outright, whatever its condition.

The counter is the block. Hit a zone shot or special shot back with perfect timing and your racket takes no damage. A racket breaks after three zone-shot hits, and if it's your last one, you forfeit the match. That threat gives defense real weight. IGN credited these systems with making Aces far more fun and "less gimmicky" than its "disappointing Wii U predecessor," Mario Tennis: Ultra Smash.

If the gauge sounds like too much, a Simple rules mode strips out every one of those moves and leaves plain tennis.

Adventure mode teaches more than it rewards

The single-player adventure mode drew the most divided reviews. GameSpot saw it as a good way for returning players to learn the new mechanics. That makes sense, since the zone system asks a lot of anyone who last played a simpler Mario Tennis.

IGN found it underdeveloped. The outlet wanted harder versions of the challenges after the credits and more to earn along the way. Both readings can be true. The mode does its job as a long tutorial but gives you little reason to come back once you've finished it.

Multiplayer has the right core and missing options

Aces is at its best against people, which makes the multiplayer complaints sting. IGN pointed out that you can't choose the court in the main modes and can't set up local tournaments. GameSpot added that the online modes don't show stats for your opponents, and it found the motion-controlled Swing Mode's detection imprecise.

The online side kept growing after launch, though. Nintendo ran monthly online tournaments, and taking part earned outfits and new characters early. If you skipped a tournament, that character joined the roster the following month. The game launched with 16 characters, from Mario and Bowser to Chain Chomp and Spike, and new ones kept arriving month by month, from Koopa Troopa in July 2018 to Dry Bowser in July 2019.

The match itself is excellent. The menus around the match are where critics docked points.

None of the complaints were about how the tennis plays. They were about how many ways the game lets you set up a match, and that held back a game critics otherwise enjoyed.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet