Analysis · Mario Tennis Fever

Mario Tennis Fever is a multiplayer game that leaves solo players short

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Built for rivalries, not for evenings alone

Mario Tennis Fever is made for people who play against other people, whether that's a friend on the couch or an opponent online. Camelot Software Planning built this Nintendo Switch 2 exclusive around fast, chaotic matches, and critics liked it most there. Players hoping for a long single-player campaign found less to do.

The scores reflect that split. Critic aggregates sit at 73% across 113 reviews and 77/100 across 108, which counts as generally favorable. The critic average, computed from those aggregates, is 7.7 out of 10. In Japan, four Famitsu critics gave it a combined 34 out of 40.

Fever Rackets turn every rally into a gamble

The big new idea is a set of 30 Fever Rackets, each with its own ability. Good play fills a Fever Gauge, and a full gauge lets you hit a Fever Shot. One shot leaves an icy patch on your opponent's side where the ball bounces. Another makes Mini Mushrooms appear that can shrink them. If the opponent is quick, they can return a Fever Shot before it lands and send the effect back across the net.

There's a health bar too. A player who takes too much damage is KO-ed and leaves the match for a while to heal. Slide shots and leap shots are also new. If all of that sounds like too much, you can turn Fever Rackets off and play Classic Tennis.

Critics largely backed the design. GameSpot's Steve Watts said the rackets helped make "the best Mario sports game in years." Shacknews' Donovan Erskine pointed to the variety and a "high skill ceiling," and IGN's Logan Plant praised the "great controls" and the multiplayer moments.

A record roster and modes to spread it across

There are 38 playable characters, the most the series has had, and Baby Waluigi appears for the first time. The modes include:

  • Tournament, with live commentary from the Talking Flower from Super Mario Bros. Wonder.
  • Trial Towers, a climb through a series of challenges to reach the top.
  • Mix It Up, which covers Ring Shot and courts with gimmicks, such as feeding Piranha Plants on the Forest Court or playing through Wonder Effects on the Wonder Court.

GameShare support lets one owner share the game with others for multiplayer, which lowers the barrier for a group. PCMag's Jordan Minor praised the modes, the unlockables and the "crisp, colorful" presentation, but noted mild lag in online matches. CBC's Jonathan Ore thought there were disappointingly few Mix It Up modes.

Adventure Mode is where it comes up short

The story mode turns the Mario cast into babies who have to learn tennis again. It's the main reason to play solo, and it's the part critics criticized most.

IGN called it "more of an extended tutorial" than an adventure. Nintendo Life's PJ O'Reilly called Fever the best game in the series, but called Adventure Mode "a letdown" that was short and basic, and criticized the lack of single-player content in general. PCMag faulted its linearity. GameSpot was the main dissenter, calling it "short and sweet" with clever boss fights.

Most critics found Adventure Mode too short to carry the game on its own.

The price is what divided critics

Several critics weighed the content against the cost. Giant Bomb's Jeff Grubb found the mechanics solid but said little outside the core tennis was fun, calling the game "lazy and rote" at $70. CBC's Ore said the $100 Cdn price would be a hard sell "even for fans." The A.V. Club's Dia Lacina judged the game competent but argued Camelot, the studio behind Golden Sun, should be allowed to make a new RPG instead.

For a group that will play it every week, the tennis is good enough to justify the price. For a solo player, the Adventure Mode and a short list of side modes mean $70 buys much less.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet