Analysis · Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain

Metal Gear Solid V's tactical sandbox is the star, not its divisive story

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Every guard post is a puzzle with a dozen answers

You play Punished "Venom" Snake, seen from behind, slipping past guards across open maps of Soviet-occupied Afghanistan and the Angola–Zaire border region in 1984. The kit is broad: binoculars, guns, explosives, decoys and the series' cardboard boxes. In keeping with Metal Gear tradition, tranquilizer darts let you get through without killing anyone, and the game nudges you toward that.

Getting around is part of the plan. You can go on foot, on horseback or in jeeps and tanks, and you can climb rock faces as a shortcut. A helicopter can be called in to fight, and airstrikes can flatten a target area or even change the weather.

Critics kept reaching for the same image. Time's Matt Peckham called the world an "unparalleled tactical toybox", Game Informer's Joe Juba compared each mission to a playground, and Destructoid's Chris Carter counted "hundreds" of loadout variations. GameSpot's Peter Brown called the play "near-impeccable".

The enemy adapts. Lean on headshots and soldiers start wearing metal helmets. Favor one tactic and patrols grow and gear up. GamesRadar+'s David Roberts felt the systems respected the player's intelligence when plans went wrong. USgamer's Kat Bailey disagreed in part, finding the room for error too thin at times.

Each mission feeds the base back home

Between sorties sits Mother Base, your headquarters. The Fulton recovery system lifts captured soldiers, animals and vehicles out of the field, and recruits staff the base so it can build better weapons and items. The currency, GMP, comes from rough diamonds, shipping containers and blueprint boxes, plus soldiers you send on missions around the world. Unlike in Peace Walker, you can walk the base on foot, and a companion app lets you check on it from a smartphone.

Upgrades reach almost everything. Snake's prosthetic arm alone can take a taser, echolocation or a remote-controlled rocket. Buddy companions join the field work:

  • D-Horse, which can wear armor and hide Snake while traveling
  • D-Dog, a wolf pup trained to help in the field
  • Quiet, a mute sniper with supernatural abilities
  • D-Walker, an agile piloted weapons platform for heavy support

How useful each one is depends on your relationship with it. The loop has friction, though. EGM's Spencer Campbell found that attacks on your Forward Operating Bases could pull you away from story missions, Peckham thought the requirements to get fast travel were excessive, and some critics were frustrated by fights with the Skulls.

A story that split critics down the middle

You pick missions in any order, and the cutscenes are shorter than the series' norm, a change Polygon's Michael McWhertor and Eurogamer's Rich Stanton welcomed. The tone is darker too. Campbell called the story "one of the strongest yet" for Metal Gear, Brown praised how it handled mature themes, and Stanton liked that it used war to explore its subject rather than celebrate the military.

The other side was loud. IGN's Vince Ingenito found the answers to the plot's questions "rushed and unsatisfying". PC Gamer's Samuel Roberts called the story "aimless" and the worst in the series, and Kotaku's Jason Schreier called it "damn unfulfilling". Several reviewers objected to key plot points living in optional audio logs, and to Snake staying almost silent during emotional scenes.

If the story is why you play Metal Gear, expect the sandbox to outshine the plot.

A late twist about who Snake really is drew the same split. Roberts of PC Gamer called it "one perfect moment in a bad story", while GamesRadar+'s Roberts felt the reveal left the story "hollow".

Polished to a shine, padded at the end

The presentation drew little argument. Carter called the Fox Engine visuals "beautiful" and the sound design "impeccable". Schreier called the game "exceptionally polished", and Bailey wrote that D-Dog moves with "almost Pixar-like" detail. Stanton singled out the voice cast as a "leap" over earlier games.

There's a lot to do. Brown wrote that no Metal Gear had offered so much content, and Japanese magazine Famitsu gave it a perfect 40/40, making it the twenty-third game to earn one. The volume has a cost near the end, though. To reach the final missions, you have to replay earlier ones on higher difficulty, and reviewers felt this padded the most emotional stretch of the plot. Roberts of PC Gamer also found the boss fights "pretty dull" next to earlier entries.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet