Metroid Prime 4's open desert hub divided critics more than anything else
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Sol Valley is where the reviews part ways
The biggest disagreement over Metroid Prime 4: Beyond is about Sol Valley, the new hub world that Samus crosses on a motorcycle called the Vi-O-La. Ollie Reynolds of Nintendo Life found it empty at first, then surprisingly interesting. He took it as proof that Metroid doesn't have to stay "confined to dense corridors" to feel like Metroid.
Others saw nothing worth the drive. IGN's Logan Plant called the valley empty of interest and said it only stretches the runtime. His sharper point was that the green crystals needed for progress can only be collected there, so you can't skip it. TechRadar's Rhys Wood called it barren and lifeless. Darran Jones of Retro Gamer went further, calling the level design poor and "a world away" from the tightness of the earlier games.
Edge raised a related problem: backtracking and a final fetch quest. It said Nintendo games rarely test patience "in so many ways at once", though it still credited the game with a "core brilliance" that makes up for it.
What that split says about who will enjoy it
The hub argument comes down to what you want from Metroid. If you love tight, interlocking rooms that keep folding back on themselves, Sol Valley is dead space between the parts you came for, and the crystal requirement makes it a chore. If you mostly want the feeling of being alone on a strange planet, a wide, quiet desert can still give you that, as it eventually did for Reynolds.
The pacing debate follows the same line. Plant said he "never felt truly lost" and thought that would help new players. Wood found some areas too linear but didn't think it hurt the game much. Plant also said the game felt more like classic 3D Legend of Zelda than old Metroid, and he meant that kindly. He liked how it moved between lonely exploration and sci-fi action setpieces across varied environments.
- Newcomers get a guided, varied adventure that rarely leaves them stuck.
- Veterans who liked getting lost may find the main path too clear and the hub too thin.
The squadmates turned out better than the previews
Before release, journalists who played a 90-minute demo went after Myles MacKenzie, a non-player character they felt broke the series' sense of isolation. Plant called that stretch "mildly annoying to downright infuriating".
By the full reviews, most critics had softened. Reynolds wrote that none of the Galactic Federation companions were as irritating as the previews suggested, and said they added a lot to the story. Wood credited the troopers with "great chemistry" and said they still left long stretches of solo exploration, even though he found Myles annoying. Plant called their presence acceptably limited, with "mostly likeable personalities".
Not everyone agreed. Jones found them forgettable, Andy Robinson of Video Games Chronicle called their use "clumsy", and Keza MacDonald of The Guardian wrote that they are "all annoying". If silence is the main reason you play Metroid, take that seriously.
Where nearly every critic agreed
The look and sound of the game won almost universal praise. Reynolds called the art design "astonishing" and the soundtrack "incredible". Wood said its atmosphere stands next to the original Metroid Prime and praised the areas outside Sol Valley.
The new psychic powers let Samus work special mechanisms, reveal hidden platforms and fire guided shots. Game Informer's Ethan Van Allen called them "a standout" in previews and praised the mouse controls. On Switch 2, a Joy-Con 2 controller can work as a mouse, much like aiming in a PC first-person shooter.
Critics flagged a few weak spots:
- Wood found the bosses and enemies short on variety.
- Some extras are locked behind Amiibo figures: the Samus Amiibo unlocks a radio that plays soundtrack selections in the desert, and the Vi-O-La Amiibo unlocks motorcycle skins.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Metroid Prime 4: Beyond en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q30749509 wikidata.org