Analysis · Metroid Prime

Metroid Prime made a first-person view serve exploration, not shooting

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A first-person adventure, not a shooter

Nintendo called Metroid Prime a "first-person adventure" rather than a first-person shooter, and the whole game is built on that idea. It was the first Metroid game with 3D graphics and a first-person view. Critics still praised it for staying faithful to the series' formula: explore, find an upgrade, then reach a place you couldn't reach before. Reviewers contrasted it with action games such as Halo. You do shoot things, but the shooting serves the exploring.

Critics responded strongly. The GameCube version holds a 97/100 aggregate across 70 critic reviews, which gives it a critic average of 9.7, calculated from those critic scores. The Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences named it Console First-Person Action Game of the Year, and it had more nominations than any other game at that ceremony.

The planet is a lock and the suit is the key

Samus Aran lands on Tallon IV to find twelve Chozo Artifacts that open the path to the Phazon meteor impact crater. To get there, she has to collect power-ups in a fixed order. The Varia Suit protects her armor from high heat, which lets her enter the volcanic regions. A new Beam opens doors that wouldn't open before. Some items only come from beating bosses.

Here the exploration idea is built into the map itself, and critics praised this part most: the level design, the varied environments and the immersive atmosphere. Hidden upgrades raise Samus' maximum health and missile ammunition, so searching off the main path gives you more health and missiles. In Morph Ball mode the game switches to a third-person view, which is another way to get into places that are otherwise out of reach.

Visors make looking part of the game

The heads-up display is designed to look like the inside of Samus' helmet. It shows a radar, a map, the missile count, a health meter and a danger meter for hazardous ground. You can switch between visors that change what you see: one uses thermal imaging, one has x-ray vision and one is a scanner.

The scanner puts the core idea to its strongest test. It finds enemy weaknesses, operates mechanisms such as force fields and elevators, and pulls backstory out of objects. You find the story yourself instead of watching it, and the only cutscenes are short ones before important battles.

Critics were split on that choice. Entertainment Weekly compared the game to a 1990s arcade game with a "pretty weak plot," and the lack of focus on story was one of the main criticisms. If you want a story that's told to you, the scan entries won't give you one.

Where the idea costs you

Critics named two costs of putting exploration first. The first is the controls. Combat relies on a lock-on that lets you circle strafe while staying aimed at an enemy. It's a scheme built for a game that isn't mainly about precise aiming. Game Informer still found it awkward, and the unusual control scheme was a common complaint among reviewers.

The second is backtracking. Because items open new areas in a fixed order, you keep going back over ground you've already covered. GamePro warned that inexperienced players "might find it exhausting" to keep returning to the same places. Prime has a hint system that gives clues about how to progress, so you're less likely to get stuck, but you still have to make the return trips.

If going back to an old room with a new tool sounds like a reward, Prime was made for you. If it sounds like a chore, you'll probably share the critics' complaint about backtracking.

Critics' praise only grew with time

The acclaim held up for years. GameSpy ranked it the third-best GameCube game in 2005. IGN named it the best GameCube game in 2007 and the 23rd-greatest game ever in 2012. In 2009, Wired named it the 10th-most influential game of the decade for bringing exploration, puzzle-solving, platforming and story into first-person shooters, crediting it with "breaking the genre free" of Doom's influence. It also became popular for speedrunning, which suits a game that rewards knowing its map well.

The game came to Wii in 2009. On GameCube, connecting to the Game Boy Advance game Metroid Fusion with a GameCube–Game Boy Advance link cable adds Samus' Fusion Suit and an emulated copy of the original Metroid (1986).

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet