Analysis · Midnight Suns

Midnight Suns plays its best hand in battle and folds at the Abbey

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Made for tactics fans who also want to hang out with heroes

Midnight Suns was made for a specific player. This player likes turn-based tactics and doesn't mind a deck of cards setting their options each turn. They also want to spend the hours between fights getting to know a cast of Marvel heroes. Firaxis Games made it a tactical role-playing game. You play the Hunter, the child of Lilith, and lead a team against her as she tries to bring her master, Chthon, back to life.

The cast comes from the Avengers, X-Men, Runaways and Midnight Sons. There are 13 playable characters in the base game, and Deadpool, Morbius, Venom and Storm came later as DLC. Critics landed on "generally favorable," according to Metacritic. The aggregate score is 83/100 across 37 reviews, and the critic average, computed from critic aggregates, is 8.3. The game was also nominated for Strategy/Simulation Game of the Year at the 26th Annual D.I.C.E. Awards.

The short version: the fights deliver for that player. The time spent at the Abbey is where critics split.

The card combat is why you show up

Each mission starts with you picking three heroes. Each hero has a customizable deck of eight cards, and the three decks get shuffled into one that you draw from every round. On each turn you get three Card Plays, two redraws and one move to reposition a hero.

  • Attack cards deal damage, and some knock enemies back into hazards or into each other.
  • Skill cards heal, redraw and apply status effects.
  • Heroic cards are each hero's signature moves. They spend Heroism, which you build up by playing the other two types.

Cards marked "quick" give back a Card Play when they finish off an enemy. Chaining them is how a good turn snowballs. You can also spend Heroism on objects in the arena for attacks that don't use a card.

Reviewers praised this system more than anything else. GameSpot's Jordan Ramée said the deck-building added unpredictability without becoming frustrating, and that it rewarded both careful planning and quick improvising. IGN's Dan Stapleton called it "radically and refreshingly different" from XCOM. He also credited the progression system with opening up new options late in a long campaign. Matt Miller at Game Informer liked the fast pace and the attack animations, and said the destructible arenas made fights feel cinematic.

Easier than XCOM 2, and critics disagreed on whether that's a flaw

Matthew Byrd of Den of Geek found it less punishing than XCOM 2 but still challenging from start to finish. Jim Trinca at VG247 was more pointed. He praised the clean interface but said the game was built to make players feel smart or lucky "without really challenging them too much." Keith Stuart of The Guardian saw it the other way and credited Firaxis for not watering down the strategy to suit casual comic book fans.

Destructoid's Chris Carter split the difference. Carter called it easy to recommend to Marvel fans and accessible to strategy newcomers, while saying it wasn't Firaxis' best work.

Critics also named some real limits on the battlefield:

  • Jon Bailes at GamesRadar wanted more enemy variety and objectives that forced bigger tactical changes.
  • Several critics disliked that heroes walk to their target on their own once you pick a card.

Life at the Abbey is where it loses people

Between missions you walk around the Abbey in third person. You research upgrades, talk with the cast and build friendships, and the Hunter can lean toward light or dark through ability choices and conversations. This half of the game is far more divisive than the fighting.

Some critics warmed to it. PC Gamer's Jeremy Peel found the scenes often searching and endearingly silly, and said the focus on friendship added "warmth and approachability." Ramée called the story intriguing, picked Magik and Nico as favorites, and praised talks that end in heartwarming or devastating reveals. Several critics also liked how the story handled difficult themes.

Others ran out of patience. Miller compared the relationship system to BioWare games and enjoyed each hero's arc, but said the interactions became repetitive and exhausting. Stapleton called it "self-insertion fan fiction," built around making every hero like the Hunter. Byrd found the Hunter both the center of the story and its least developed character, and pointed to plenty of "bad one-liners." The Verge's Kevin Nguyen called everything outside combat "a slog" full of filler. Bailes said the morning preparations could feel like a "checklist of chores." Several critics were also let down by the facial capture.

The more you value story and dialogue, the more this game will test you between fights.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet