Analysis · Minecraft: Nintendo Switch Edition

Minecraft on Switch suits newcomers, not players who know the PC version

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Built for players picking up Minecraft with a controller

This edition was made for someone new to Minecraft who wants to play it on a Nintendo Switch, alone and with a gamepad. It's rated Everyone 10+ and lists only single-player mode, which points it at younger players and anyone who wants to build in handheld mode without learning a keyboard-and-mouse game.

It came out on May 11, 2017, as the last of 4J Studios' ports of Minecraft to seventh- and eighth-generation consoles. Those ports are now called the "legacy console editions," a group that started on Xbox 360 and ended with the Switch.

Where it delivers: controls and crafting made for a gamepad

Critics agreed that the legacy editions got the controls right. Eurogamer's Oli Welsh called them "taut, fast and logical," and IGN's Anthony Gallegos said 4J Studios "smartly recreated the crafting system" while staying close to the PC original.

The crafting rework is the main thing a newcomer gains. Instead of the PC version's grid, the console editions use a simpler menu. Welsh admitted that this smooths away part of what makes the PC game distinct, but he still thought the console version was better for beginners. Gallegos went further and argued that most newcomers wouldn't miss the cut features, because the core mechanics and recipes are all there.

The Switch edition did better than most of the family. Oliver Brandt of Vooks said it was "more similar to the PC version of Minecraft" and praised its larger worlds, and IGN's Alanah Pearce called it an "authentic Minecraft experience." Aggregate scores back that up: a count of 17 reviews landed at 87/100, and the critic average, calculated from critic aggregates, is 8.7.

Where it falls short: a world with walls

The most common complaint about the legacy editions was world size. The PC version's worlds are close to infinite, but the console worlds stop at a border. Game Informer's Cork measured the Xbox 360 worlds at about 1,000 blocks across, and GameSpot's Nathan Meunier called the loss of infinite maps disappointing.

The Switch edition's worlds are bigger than the oldest ports, but they're still finite. That matters less to a beginner than it sounds. Cork said he only hit the invisible walls when he went looking for them. Players who like to travel far from spawn will feel the limit sooner.

Critics also pointed out features that the PC version had and the console editions didn't. The Guardian's Keith Stuart wrote that the Xbox 360 Edition was "more limited than the current PC iteration." Welsh noted that "purists might find this version a little dumbed down."

Why it's frozen where it stopped

When Stuart reviewed the Xbox 360 Edition, he treated it as a work in progress that needed to grow. That argument doesn't hold for the Switch edition anymore. Mojang discontinued the legacy console editions in favor of Bedrock Edition, so the gaps critics flagged here aren't going to be filled.

Some players liked these editions as they were. The YouTuber Joseph Garrett, known as Stampy, said in 2017 that he had "mixed feelings" about the change. He liked that there had been one version of Minecraft that matched across consoles, and he was openly critical of Bedrock Edition by comparison.

Buy this edition for what it is now: a tidy, finished version of Minecraft for a controller, not one that will keep growing.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet