Analysis · MLB 14: The Show

MLB 14 moved the Show to PS4 and kept almost everything else the same

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The ninth Show was the first on PS4

MLB 14: The Show is the ninth game in Sony's baseball series and the one that brought it to the PlayStation 4. San Diego Studio released it on April 1, 2014, for the PlayStation 3 and PlayStation Vita, and a PS4 version came out the same year. That makes it a bridge between two generations of hardware.

Critics saw it the same way. Matt Beaudette of Hardcore Gamer called it "excellent," but he judged that most of the year's work went into getting the game running on PS4 with new graphics. That sums up what changed in 2014. The big differences were the platform and the look, not the baseball.

The PS4 move improved the graphics but added little else

The upgrade critics talked about was visual. They didn't highlight a new mode or a reworked system. Ryan McCaffrey of IGN scored it 8.1/10 and said it plainly: there were "few exciting new features" this year.

His other complaint matters more if you play against other people. When IGN reviewed it, online play was "very laggy." That's a real gap in a sports game built for multiplayer. Of the outlets quoted here, IGN is the only one to name a specific technical flaw.

Fans bought the new version quickly anyway. Within its first week, the PS4 edition became the fastest-selling game in the series up to that point.

The modes and the broadcast stayed strong

The strengths are the ones the series already had. IGN again called it a "stellar baseball simulation," with enough good modes to last a full season. The praise was for how much there is to play, not for anything new.

The presentation got the warmest reviews. Jack DeVries of GameSpot gave it 8/10 and singled out the commentary. He called it lively and informative, with more humor than you might expect. A baseball season is long, and play-by-play repeats over that many games. Commentary that holds up over that stretch adds a lot.

Some things stayed the same off the field too. Detroit Tigers first baseman Miguel Cabrera is on the cover. For the third year in a row, Canada got its own cover, this time with Toronto Blue Jays third baseman Brett Lawrie.

Critic scores land around 8 out of 10

  • Hardcore Gamer: 4/5
  • IGN: 8.1/10
  • GameSpot: 8/10
  • Aggregate of 10 reviews, PlayStation 4 version: 80/100
  • Aggregate of 10 reviews, PlayStation 3 version: 80/100
  • Aggregate of 25 reviews, as of May 30, 2014: 82/100, or 88%

The Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences nominated it for Sports Game of the Year at the 18th Annual D.I.C.E. Awards. The critic average, calculated from these critic aggregates, is 8.1 out of 10.

The main takeaway: this is a strong baseball game that changed little apart from its platform. If you already own an earlier Show, the reason to upgrade is how the PS4 version looks. If you're new to the series, the reason to play is everything the series already did well.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet