MLB The Show 16 polishes strong baseball and adds perks that split critics
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A strong baseball engine, tuned rather than rebuilt
MLB The Show 16 is built on one idea that critics kept coming back to: the baseball was already very good, so this entry refines it. It's the eleventh installment in the MLB: The Show series, developed by San Diego Studio. Reviewers judged it less on new features than on whether the tweaks made an already good formula better.
Polygon put it most clearly. The changes "may not be breakthroughs," it wrote, but they fix parts of the game that had felt routine or "chorelike." Destructoid made the same point with an edge, saying the series seemed to be coasting on good gameplay with minor tweaks to its modes, while still calling the baseball "as good as ever." IGN was the most enthusiastic and called it "the best baseball game available on any current-gen console."
Metacritic recorded generally positive reviews. The critic average, computed from critic aggregates, is 8.5 out of 10.
Where the polish paid off
Judged against that idea of refinement, the on-field game and its presentation are where the work showed most. The praise was specific and widespread:
- IGN commended the animations, graphics and load times.
- GameSpot singled out the lighting, stadium detail and range of options, along with the game's incremental improvements.
- GamesRadar+ rated the pitching engine, presentation, accessibility and roster updates highly.
- Shacknews liked the quality-of-life improvements and the amount of content.
Road to the Show, the career mode, is the clearest case of a weak spot being fixed. Destructoid called it one of the better modes and said it was "far less clunky" this time. GameRevolution, the least positive of the major outlets, still praised how the game represents an MLB career.
The perks that pulled it away from simulation
The refinement idea runs into trouble with the game's newer systems: consumable perks, a morale system and the card-collecting Diamond Dynasty mode. Critics didn't agree on whether these were improvements or a change of direction.
IGN counted the perks and morale system as added depth. Game Informer went further and praised the move away from strict authenticity, comparing the new feel to a superhero game. GameSpot praised the Conquest and Diamond Dynasty modes heavily, and Shacknews liked the perks.
The pushback was just as specific. GameRevolution was frustrated by the new focus on RPG elements. GameSpot and Shacknews both counted microtransactions against the game, and GameSpot listed the perks as a negative too. USgamer's verdict sums up the split:
"If you're a returning player, your mileage will probably vary depending on how willing you are to indulge in The Show's card-collecting mode." (USgamer)
What the tweaks didn't reach
Refinement still left some rough parts. Destructoid had the longest list: no collision physics, the Quick Count system, technical issues, the commentary and a soundtrack it called mediocre. Shacknews pointed to lag and finicky controls. GamesRadar+ called the scouting system and the sheer bloat of content minor negatives.
Visuals split critics. Most praised them, but GameRevolution called the graphics dated, even while saying the game "looks better than ever."
Where it stands now
The game came out on March 29, 2016, for PlayStation 3 and PlayStation 4. It was the final entry released on PlayStation 3 and the first in the series without a portable version. Its servers shut down on July 28, 2020, so the parts of the game that depended on them, including online play, no longer work. That matters most for anyone drawn to the card-collecting side.
It was nominated for Sports Game of the Year at the 20th Annual D.I.C.E. Awards. For a newcomer who likes baseball, USgamer's advice still holds: the baseball sim underneath is "extremely strong."
Sources
- Wikipedia: MLB The Show 16 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q21772564 wikidata.org