MLB The Show 20 wins on the field, and critics split on its new extras
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The split is over the extras, not the baseball
Critics barely argued about the core game. IGN, Game Informer and GameSpot all scored it 8 or higher, and Game Informer and GameSpot both praised the reworked hitting and fielding by name. OpenCritic reports that 93% of critics recommended it, and Metacritic labels the reception "generally favorable."
The disagreement shows up in the new features around the game. GameSpot gave it 8/10 and liked the fielding and hitting, but it faulted two additions: custom teams and Online Leagues. Game Informer, at 8.75/10, came away more positive about the new material, especially in Diamond Dynasty. Its summary called the game "additions across the board" with gameplay that rewards skill.
IGN landed in between at 8.7/10. It said this "isn't the biggest upgrade the series has ever seen," while also finding "no real downsides." Put those three reviews together and the takeaway is plain. The baseball improved, and the new modes are a question of taste.
Players who care about each at-bat get the most out of it
Critics agreed most about hitting and fielding, so the game is easiest to recommend to people who spend their time at the plate and in the field. Game Informer's point that the game "emphasizes skill" matters here. Good timing and clean defensive play pay off, and that is the part of the game reviewers trusted.
If you already play the series every season for its baseball, nothing in the reviews says this year slipped. IGN is also honest that it's a step forward, not a leap.
Franchise and prospect fans get real additions
Two changes give long-term players something new to do:
- Licensed minor leaguers. This is the first time Minor League Baseball players appear in the series with their real names and likenesses. Earlier games filled those rosters with generic players. If you like tracking prospects up through a farm system, this is the biggest change of the year.
- A team and logo editor in Franchise mode. This editor used to be available only in Diamond Dynasty. Now you can use it while building a club over several seasons.
Diamond Dynasty players get new features too, and Game Informer singled those out for praise.
Who should be more careful
If custom teams or Online Leagues are why you'd buy it, take GameSpot's criticism seriously. It is the most specific complaint any of these reviews made, and it hits the features that are supposed to set this year apart. If you want a big generational jump, IGN's "not the biggest upgrade" points the same way.
The broadcast team is mostly familiar. Matt Vasgersian, Mark DeRosa and Dan Plesac return for play-by-play, Heidi Watney returns as sideline reporter, and Alex Miniak returns on the public address. Returning players will find that comfortable. Anyone hoping for a fresh-sounding booth won't get one.
The consensus pick: buy it for the swing and the glove, and treat the new modes as a bonus rather than the reason to upgrade.
Where it sits in the series
The Show 20 is the 15th game in the series and the last one released only on PlayStation, made by San Diego Studio for the PlayStation 4, with Javier Báez of the Chicago Cubs on the cover. The Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences nominated it for Sports Game of the Year at the 24th D.I.C.E. Awards. Its critic average of 8.3 out of 10, calculated from the critic aggregates, matches what the reviews describe: a strong, steady entry that didn't try to remake itself.
Sources
- Wikipedia: MLB The Show 20 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q74120494 wikidata.org