Analysis · Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2

Modern Warfare 2 lives on its multiplayer and a short, loud campaign

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Made for players who want a blockbuster campaign and a long online grind

Modern Warfare 2 was made for players who want two things from a shooter: a campaign that plays like an action movie and an online mode they can stick with for months. It delivers both, and critics at launch rated it near the top of its year. Aggregate scores reached 94/100 on PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360 and 86/100 on PC. The critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 8.4 out of 10.

It falls short for three kinds of player: those who want a long story, those hoping for new ideas from the series, and PC players who expect control over their own servers. Each of those complaints shows up in the launch reviews.

The campaign hits hard and ends fast

The campaign has 18 levels tied together by one plot, and the player often switches soldiers between them. Each level sets a list of objectives, checkpoints restart you when you die, and you can replay any finished level on one of four difficulty settings. The kit changes from mission to mission: night vision goggles in one, a laser designator in another, a heartbeat sensor on a rifle.

Critics loved the spectacle. 1UP.com pointed to its "bombastic set-pieces" and said it kept the guided, thrill-ride structure of the first Modern Warfare. Later retrospectives singled out its pacing, its emotional weight and the shock of the "No Russian" mission as reasons it ranks among the series' best campaigns.

The catch is length. IGN's Mark Bozon called the single-player "surprisingly short" and said it fell below the standard of earlier Call of Duty games. Several reviewers also faulted the lack of new ideas in the formula. If the story is your main reason to buy, expect a short, dense campaign rather than a long one.

Multiplayer earned the reputation, imbalances and all

Most of the praise went to the multiplayer. Matches are team-based or deathmatch-style across a spread of maps. Experience points from kills, objectives and finished matches raise your level and open up new weapons. Kill three players in a row without dying and you earn a killstreak; the rewards include a sentry gun, a Predator missile and a tactical nuke. Die several times without a kill and a deathstreak bonus helps even the fight.

GameTrailers called it "the best multiplayer shooting experience" in the industry at launch. Years later, ComicBook.com's Cade Onder ranked it among the "most defining" multiplayer games of its generation, and in 2021 TheGamer's Cian Maher named it the best multiplayer shooter of all time. Maps such as Terminal and Rust became fan favorites.

The same retrospectives that praise the multiplayer also flag balance problems that could make matches frustrating, and at times game-breaking.

The Tactical Nuke killstreak and grenade-launcher spam, known as "noob-tubing", were the usual culprits. If lopsided matches wear you down, count that as a real cost.

Spec Ops gives two players a reason to stay

Spec Ops is easy to overlook, but critics name it as one of the series' best modes. It adds 23 short challenge levels you can play alone or with a partner, such as defusing three bombs against a tight clock. In co-op, a downed player crawls and keeps firing a handgun until revived. If the partner doesn't reach them in time, they die and the level fails.

The levels sit in five tiers. Only the first is open at the start, and you earn stars to open the rest. Each finished level awards stars based on which of three difficulties you chose. That gives two friends a clear ladder to climb once the campaign is done.

The PC version shipped with strings attached

The Windows version drew the harshest criticism. It launched without dedicated servers and ran matchmaking through IWNet instead. Infinity Ward said it would also lack console commands, cap matches at 18 players and give players no way to ban cheaters. Ars Technica's Ben Kuchera warned it would be among the most "locked-down" games ever made, and a petition for dedicated servers passed 150,000 signatures in ten days. The PC aggregate of 86/100 sits well below the console scores.

The game also drew some smaller controversies. Some journalists criticized the Karachi multiplayer map for using Arabic rather than Urdu on its signs. A "don't ask, don't tell" line hidden in the tutorial drew complaints too, though some journalists thought the reaction was overblown.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet