Analysis · Mordhau

Mordhau's sword fights reward patience, and its learning curve punishes it

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The best and worst of it come from the same place

GameSpot's James Swinbanks called Mordhau "strategic, punishing and ultimately satisfying". In the same review he described the early hours as a "slow, merciless grind" of dying over and over while you learn. Both claims are about one thing: a sword-fighting system that asks a lot and gives back a lot once you meet it.

Critics mostly liked that trade. The game holds 81 on Metacritic across 21 critic reviews, and the critic average, worked out from those critic aggregates, is 8.2 out of 10. The disagreements were about how much pain the game asks for up front, and who it leaves out.

Why the combat earned the praise

Mordhau is a first- or third-person hack and slash game about close fighting with swords, spears, shields, hammers and more. You aim strikes in a direction, stab, kick, dodge, block and parry, all while watching your health and stamina. Its system draws loosely on historical techniques like feints, redirecting a swing partway through, and using a weapon in other ways than its edge. Horses, bows and siege engines round out the battlefield.

Reviewers kept coming back to how far that system goes:

  • Destructoid's Patrick Hancock liked discovering combos that led players toward their own style of fighting.
  • IGN's Samuel Horti liked the steady sense of getting better as the mechanics sank in.
  • Game Informer's Javy Gwaltney wrote that each step of improvement is paid back with "spectacular displays of violence".

That last point matters. A deep system only feels good if progress is visible, and critics said here it is.

Where it fails new players

The sharpest complaints are about teaching. GameSpot and IGN both said the in-game tutorial doesn't explain the mechanics well enough. Swinbanks added that hits don't give clear enough feedback, which makes it hard to tell why you lost an exchange. Horti said he learned from video tutorials and wished he could learn by playing instead of "turning to YouTube guides".

PC Gamer's T.J. Hafer raised a different worry. Players who want a supporting role in a big battle, rather than winning duels, may find the game "doesn't support that playstyle especially well". In a game built around one-on-one skill, there isn't much room for anyone else.

The rule of thumb from the reviews: expect to lose a lot, and plan to study outside the game.

Big battles, build points and a missing mode

Most of the action is team play for up to 64 players. In Frontline, two teams start with 1000 points each and lose them as their players die and territory falls; finishing a team objective ends the match at once. In Invasion, attackers push through objectives against a timer while defenders fall back. Horde puts a small team against harder and harder waves of computer-controlled enemies, buying weapons and armor with currency earned from kills.

A Battle Royale mode for 64 players once existed but has been taken down.

Between matches you build a mercenary on a points budget. Heavier armor costs more and slows you down, bigger weapons cost more than a light dagger, and perks add passive abilities priced by how useful they are. Looks, faces and voices are free to change. It's a simple way to make every loadout a tradeoff.

The community problem critics wrote about

In July 2019, Horti wrote in PC Gamer that Mordhau's player base had a toxicity problem, with players using homophobic, racist or sexist language in matches and on the forums and not being punished enough. He criticized Triternion's hands-off approach to word filters and bans, which the studio framed as avoiding censorship.

The piece also raised talk of letting players turn off female and non-white characters. Triternion later said that idea had been briefly discussed and dropped, and stated on its forums that such toggles were "out of the question". The story was picked up widely. It doesn't change how the combat plays, but in an online-only game, the people you fight are part of the product.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet