Analysis · The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind

Morrowind traded Daggerfall's generic world for one striking island

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The third entry bet everything on one island

Morrowind came out in 2002 as the third game in The Elder Scrolls, following 1996's The Elder Scrolls II: Daggerfall. It was also Bethesda's first major title made for a console, released on Xbox as well as Windows. It puts you on Vvardenfell, an island in the Dunmer province of Morrowind. The main quest centers on the demigod Dagoth Ur, who sits inside the volcano Red Mountain and wants to break Morrowind free of Imperial rule.

The biggest change from Daggerfall is in the world itself. Reviewers had found Daggerfall's design generic, and by comparison they called Morrowind's varied and stunning. Critics praised its real-time weather, its day and night cycle, and the range of plants and creatures. GameSpot said that simply exploring was "possibly the best thing" about the game, and Xbox Nation named its "sheer scope" as the main selling point.

What it kept: you get better by doing

The character system carries Daggerfall's thinking forward. Skills and attributes are separate. Skills are narrow, like a weapon type or an armor class, and they rise through use. Hit enemies with a blade to improve with blades, or get hit while wearing heavy armor to improve heavy armor. You can also pay trainers for quick gains or read books that raise a skill on the spot.

Attributes such as strength and endurance only rise when you level up, and leveling comes from ten major and minor skills you pick at the start. Each level lets you raise three attributes, with bigger boosts for the ones tied to the skills you've been using. Character creation is folded into the opening, as a freed prisoner answers questions from a fellow inmate, an officer and a bureaucrat. You can pick a class from a list, answer questions to get one, or design your own.

Critics mostly liked it. GameSpy said the system made other role-playing games look "silly by comparison", and GameSpot called it clear and sensible. IGN found the classes well balanced, though it thought the manual explained the system poorly. The dissent was specific: PC Gamer felt combat got more than its share, and Computer Gaming World said one-handed weapons with shields could be exploited over two-handed weapons.

Where it stumbles: the fights and the paperwork

Combat was the most common complaint about how the game plays. GameSpot called it one of the major weak points, and reviewers found it simple and prone to boredom. If you come for fighting, expect the least loved part of the design.

The journal drew even harsher words. It adds entries automatically after conversations and story beats, one after another, with no way to sort by quest or by whether a quest is done. Reviewers described it as a "muddled mess" running to hundreds of pages, and Computer Gaming World called it a "nightmare of confusion". The Tribunal expansion later organized it by quest, which eased much of the problem.

Critics also pointed to glitches and steep hardware demands, with one reviewer calling it "a resource pig". Xbox Nation added slowdowns, long travel times and tangled quests to the list. Still, IGN concluded that the game's accomplishments "outweigh any reservations", and GameSpot judged the drawbacks minor enough to look past.

The Xbox version gave up mods but not its reputation

On Xbox, critics disliked the lower resolution and the lack of add-on modifications, which the Windows version supports. They felt the detail and freedom made up for it. Morrowind was the best-selling role-playing game on Xbox in 2002 and stayed in the console's top 10 from May through October 2003, a run matched only by Halo. Despite that, the Xbox release won no end-of-year press awards.

A 1Up retrospective went further than praise: it argued that Morrowind's open-endedness helped steer computer players toward online role-playing games, where they could find a similar freedom.

The critic average of 9.0 is computed from those critic aggregates, not from a separate verdict. It fits a game whose world was ahead of its systems.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet