Mortal Kombat X fights brilliantly but stumbles online and on PC
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Among the best fighting games in years, with a weak online spine
At its best, Mortal Kombat X earned the kind of praise few fighting games get. Game Informer's Brian Shea called it one of the "best fighting games in years". IGN's Vince Ingenito went further: he called it the best game in the series' history, deeper, mechanically richer and more fully featured than the entries before it.
The sharpest criticism was about something else. PC Gamer's Matt Elliott wrote that its online play "simply isn't sturdy enough" to stay competitive. GameSpot's Peter Brown said it had the best fighting mechanics in the series, yet he still faulted the downloadable content for "blatant monetization". Critics kept making the same split: a superb fighting system inside an online and business layer they trusted far less.
Three versions of every fighter keep the roster fresh
Each character comes in three variations, and each variation has its own set of moves. Scorpion, for example, can fight with dual swords in his Ninjutsu variation, use fire attacks in Hellfire, or summon hellspawn minions in Inferno. Picking a fighter also means picking a style, so the same matchup can play out in several different ways.
Underneath is a three-section energy meter. One section powers an enhanced special move, two break an opponent's combo, and all three trigger an X-Ray move. A new two-section stamina meter limits running, back dashes, combo breakers and stage interactions. Those interactions let fighters use the scenery to reposition themselves or pick up objects as weapons.
Game Revolution's Nick Tan praised the variations and the environmental attacks. He also liked the Brutalities, which now trigger when certain moves land as the final blow. At IGN, Ingenito credited the shaken-up roster with making the game feel new to both longtime and casual fans.
Not everyone was won over. VentureBeat's Stephen Kleckner found some move animations confusing and felt the system favored close-range mid-to-high combos. He also disliked having to use the block button to run.
The story mode carries the single-player side
Story mode links its fights with cutscenes, and it drew some of the warmest reviews. GamesRadar's Lucas Sullivan called it "ceaselessly entertaining" and praised its voice acting and its surprisingly enjoyable script. VideoGamer.com's Brett Phipps also singled out the story and summed up the whole game as "absurd, gruesome ridiculous fun".
The rest of the solo package got less enthusiasm. Sullivan criticized the other single-player modes and called the tutorial options "sparse". That's a real gap in a game that asks newcomers to learn three variations per fighter. Tan liked the Tower system, including Living Towers, which updates the old Challenge Tower with changing play conditions. He still disliked the story's ending, missed Stage Fatalities and tag-team matches, and felt the game had been purposely "truncated".
Online play, paid extras and the PC version drew the complaints
Online, there's plenty to choose from:
- ranked and random 1 vs. 1 matches
- King of the Hill, Survivor and Test Your Luck
- Faction Wars, an ongoing cross-platform contest where players join one of five factions and earn points and rewards for it
GameTrailers' Michael Huber counted the new online features among the game's strengths. The connections behind them were another matter. Phipps was annoyed by online "hiccups", Kleckner called the online play poor, and Elliott judged it too shaky for competitive use. Kleckner also objected to DLC that made Fatalities easy to perform. Brown's complaint about monetization carries extra weight because he otherwise loved the game.
PC players have the most reason for caution. High Voltage Software developed the Windows version, and QLOC took over shortly after Kombat Pack 1 launched. Kleckner reported a bug that erased save data on PC. Metacritic's figures show the gap: 86/100 on Xbox One, 83/100 on PlayStation 4 and 76/100 on Windows.
Destructoid's Chris Carter expected the game to get better as more characters arrived through DLC. The critic average, calculated from the critic aggregates, is 8.6 out of 10.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Mortal Kombat X en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q17118361 wikidata.org