Muse Dash wins critics over with two buttons, cute Muses and a sweet soundtrack
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Loved for its simplicity, scored as middling
The strongest praise for Muse Dash came from Mike Fahey at Kotaku. He wrote that rhythm games don't get much "simpler and sweeter", and he singled out the two-button controls, the music selection and the charming characters. Nintendo World Report gave it 8.5/10 for its "fun and colorful presentation". CGMagazine gave it 8/10 and said it has enough good content to keep rhythm fans busy for a long time.
The overall numbers are cooler. Metacritic labels the game "mixed or average" with a 73/100. A critic aggregate taken on April 22, 2022 across 19 reviews shows 75/100, and another reading of that set shows 68%. The critic average, calculated from those critic aggregates, is 7.5 out of 10.
That gap is the main tension. The reviews quoted by name are warm, but enough critics were less impressed to pull the average into the middle. No specific complaint is on record, so the fair reading is that the game pleased everyone a little and only some reviewers a lot.
Two buttons carry the whole game
Enemies and obstacles come in from the right side of the screen, and you clear them by pressing a button or tapping the screen in time with the song. There are only two buttons. That makes the game easy to learn, and critics counted it as a strength rather than a limit.
Most songs have more than one difficulty setting, so the same track can work for a newcomer and for someone chasing a cleaner run. It's a 2D side-scroller that mixes action and music, with every action tied to the beat.
The same design is the most likely reason for the mixed scores. A game built on two inputs has a low floor, and players who want rhythm games that keep adding new mechanics may run out of surprises sooner. That's an inference from the design, not a complaint any critic is quoted making, but it fits the space between Kotaku's delight and the 68% figure.
Muses and Elfins add a light layer of choice
The playable characters are called Muses. Each Muse's maximum health and passive skill depend on the costume you pick, so a costume changes how forgiving a run is, not just how it looks.
You can also equip an Elfin, a companion that rides along with your Muse. Most Elfins add an ability of their own. Put together, this lets you tilt a run toward survival or toward a particular passive bonus without adding any buttons.
This layer is small, and that seems deliberate. It gives players something to tinker with between songs while the moment-to-moment play stays as simple as critics described.
The sound and art earned the awards
Muse Dash's presentation got recognition beyond reviews, and almost all of it was for the audio and visuals:
- At TapTap's 2018 Game Awards it was nominated for Best Audio, Best Visual Art and Gamer's Choice, and won Gamer's Choice.
- At BitSummit Vol. 6 in 2018 it was an Official Selection and was nominated for The Excellence in Sound Design Award.
Those awards line up with the reviews. Kotaku praised the music selection, and Nintendo World Report praised the colorful look. In a rhythm game the soundtrack is the main thing you're playing, so strong praise for the music matters more than it would in most genres.
Where and how to play it
PeroPeroGames, based in China, made the game, and hasuhasu and XD Network published it in Japan. It came out on iOS and Android in June 2018 and reached Nintendo Switch, Windows and macOS in June 2019. It's single-player only and is rated Teen and PEGI 12.
The two-button design suits a touchscreen as well as a controller, so the platform matters less here than in most rhythm games. Choose the device you already reach for during short breaks, because the game is built for quick sessions.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Muse Dash en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q55332309 wikidata.org