Analysis · Napoleon: Total War

Napoleon's battles won critics over, but some saw only Empire underneath

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The real argument was whether it's a new game

Critics didn't really argue about whether Napoleon plays well. They argued about whether it's a new game. Most came down in favor: Metacritic rated the reception "generally favorable," and the critic aggregate behind the critic average of 8.4 is 84/100 across 20 reviews.

The dissenters were blunt. GameSpy's Tom Chick gave it 2.0 out of 5, citing bad AI and a game that felt like "a re-skinned Empire." Game Revolution called it an "expansion at best" being sold as a brand new game.

Both camps were describing the same thing. Napoleon keeps Empire: Total War's frame: a turn-based map where you build, research, trade and wage war, then real-time battles with muskets, cannons, sabers and bayonets. Revolts and revolutions work much as they did. To one reviewer that's a refined version of a good game. To another it's the same game twice.

Why most critics came down on its side

The battles carried the praise. IGN called them some of "the most amazing" it had seen in any game, and Gameplanet said they left Empire behind, with five times more particles per effect. GameSpot liked an interface that never feels cluttered and keeps most of the screen on the fighting.

The changes underneath are small but real:

  • Attrition appears on the campaign map for the first time in the series, so armies lose men to heat or snow depending on where they march.
  • Losses refill on their own in friendly territory, which cuts out a lot of busywork.
  • You can win a major campaign once you hold enough territory, without waiting for the final turn.
  • Famous battles stand on their own as historical scenarios, including the Pyramids, Austerlitz, Borodino and Waterloo, plus Lodi, Arcole, the Nile, Trafalgar, Dresden and Ligny.

Outside recognition followed. It won Best PC Game at the Milthon European Game Awards in Paris in September 2010, and composers Richard Beddow, Richard Birdsall and Ian Livingstone won an Ivor Novello Award for the score in May 2011.

Where even the fans hedged

The AI split critics almost as sharply as the Empire question did. Eurogamer said it sometimes makes poor decisions but will still "hold its own" and give a challenge that suits the difficulty. GameSpy saw nothing to defend.

Other complaints came up across reviews:

  • The story campaigns felt somewhat linear.
  • Naval battles ran long.
  • The netcode was unstable, which matters if you're buying it for multiplayer.

Actiontrip still called it a good strategy game but said it gives you less freedom in how you handle battle situations. That sits awkwardly next to the praise for the battles: critics agreed they look superb but disagreed on how much room they leave to improvise.

Which side you'll land on

If Empire is already in your library, think of Napoleon as an expansion and price it that way. If it isn't, this is the more polished way into the gunpowder era.

The four campaigns cover a range of tastes. Two follow Napoleon's early career, the Italian campaign of 1796–1797 and the invasion of Egypt in 1798, with optional side missions that move the story along. Mastery of Europe is the open, conquer-everything mode the series is known for, and France is close to immune from revolution there, which makes it an easier start. Campaigns of the Coalition flip the war, putting you in charge of Great Britain, Russia, Prussia or Austria against Napoleonic France.

The tutorial walks through Napoleon's younger years, including the Siege of Toulon and the first Battle of Algeciras. That's a gentle start for players new to the series.

Players who want staged history and big set-piece battles got the most out of it, by the critics' account. The players most likely to be let down are the ones who already know Empire well. They're also the ones best placed to notice how much is shared.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet