Analysis · Natural Doctrine

Natural Doctrine punishes tactics fans more than it rewards them

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Made for players who want a tactics game to fight back

Natural Doctrine is a 2014 tactical role-playing game for the PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4 and PlayStation Vita. Its audience is clear: players who like turn-based battles on a grid and want them hard. The game draws on the idea of natural selection. You play as Geoff, the main character, with two companions named Vasily and Anka. Outside the city of Feste, minotaurs, goblins and orcs build bases and attack from them.

If you want a forgiving campaign with plenty of room to try things, this isn't it. If you want a game that punishes every misstep, it was built for you. Critics agreed on the first half of that. They weren't sure the punishment was fair.

Where the design delivers

The ideas behind the combat stand out, and critics noticed them. The game puts large numbers of allies and enemies on a big battlefield at once, not a handful of units on a small map. Time can be controlled as the fight unfolds, and several units can share a single space.

Two systems give battles some extra layers:

  • Encampments. Units fighting each other form camps. At the end of a turn they can fall back to camp, as long as the camp hasn't been destroyed. Protecting the camp becomes part of the fight.
  • Cover. Units can hide behind objects, so where you stand matters as much as what you attack.

Heath Hindman of PlayStation LifeStyle reviewed the Japanese PlayStation 4 import and called the mechanics interesting. That's the strongest praise the reception gives, and it's aimed at the right target: the ideas underneath the game.

There's also more to it than the campaign. The game has versus and co-op multiplayer, and in multiplayer you can play as the non-human species. It supports cross-play and cross-save across platforms. The online mode adds a card battle game where players build their own decks and face each other.

Where it lets those players down

Good ideas didn't save the experience of playing. Hindman's review pointed to three problems:

  • the user interface needed more work;
  • the level design needed more work;
  • the pacing was slower than it should have been.

Hardcore Gamer went further and named the problem that matters most to this audience:

Hardcore Gamer called the game "punishing, unfair at times" and said it pushes players down a narrow path that leaves almost no room for tactical experimentation.

That's a serious charge against a tactics game. Players who enjoy hard tactics games want difficulty that rewards clever plans. If a level allows only one real way through, the challenge becomes a puzzle with one answer. Losing then feels like failing to guess what the designer wanted, not like getting outplayed. A game built on natural selection, with big battlefields and camps that can fall, sounds like it should allow many ways to win. Critics said it mostly doesn't.

What the numbers say

The scores sit firmly in the middle. Metacritic listed the game's reviews as "mixed" on every platform. The critic aggregates in our data range from 48/100 across 8 reviews for the PlayStation 4 and PlayStation 3 versions to 57/100 across 35 reviews. Japan's Famitsu was kinder, scoring the PlayStation 3 and PlayStation 4 versions with one seven and three eights, and the Vita version with one six and three eights.

Players in Japan didn't rush to buy it either. Only 18,000 physical retail copies sold across the three platforms in the first week. By July 2014 it had sold over 50,000 units across all three.

The pattern is easy to read. Critics who judged the ideas were fairly generous. Critics who judged the experience of playing were not.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet