Analysis · NBA 2K23

NBA 2K23 drew award buzz from critics and pay-to-win anger from players

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Award-worthy to critics, pay-to-win to players

Critics and players remember NBA 2K23 differently. Critics gave it what Metacritic calls "generally favorable" reviews, with a 78/100 on PS5 and 80/100 on Xbox. At the 26th Annual D.I.C.E. Awards, the Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences nominated it for Sports Game of the Year.

Players saw a different game. Their sharpest complaint was that finishing a MyCareer player took over $100 in VC on top of the price of the game. Many said the mode felt pay-to-win and left anyone who couldn't or wouldn't spend at a real disadvantage.

Both accounts stand. Critics judged the basketball and the package. Players judged what it cost to keep up, and that is the part that turns a good score into a hard sell.

The scores are consistent across every console

The critic numbers barely move from version to version. One aggregate, built from 17 reviews, gives 81/100 on every platform it lists: PS5, Xbox Series X and Series S, Switch, PS4, Xbox One and Windows. That's unusual for a series that ships on both older and newer hardware.

A second aggregator, measured on April 9, 2023, comes in a little lower: 78/100 across 87 reviews and 70% across 86. The critic average of 8.0 is computed from these critic aggregates by a published formula and is not a staff rating. It puts the game in clearly good territory, but well short of a must-play.

MyCareer charged extra to keep up

The VC complaint goes beyond grumbling about optional cosmetics. Players described a mode where building a competitive player was designed around spending money, and where people who didn't pay fell behind those who did.

A full-price sports game that charges again to make your own player competitive is asking you to pay twice.

If MyCareer was the reason you wanted the game, those complaints should weigh more than the critic averages. If you mainly wanted to play quick games or seasons with real NBA teams, they matter less.

Newer consoles got more features and more lag complaints

The new eras were available only on PS5 and Xbox Series X. Players on PS4, Xbox One and PC didn't get them and said so. Players on PS5 and Xbox Series X, meanwhile, reported frame rate dips and lag.

That leaves no clean choice of version. The newer consoles had the extra content and also most of the performance complaints. The older versions avoided some of those complaints but lost a headline feature. The NBA 2K23 Arcade Edition, released on Apple Arcade for iOS, macOS and tvOS on October 18, 2022, is a separate edition and isn't covered by the critic scores listed here.

The online servers closed on December 31, 2024

This one fact matters most for anyone thinking about buying the game now. The online servers for NBA 2K23 shut down on December 31, 2024. Nothing that needed those servers works anymore, and the online multiplayer is part of that.

What's left is the offline single-player and local co-op game that critics rated well, in a series that has kept releasing newer entries since. NBA 2K23 is rated Everyone and PEGI 3, so it's still suitable for a family console. For new players, though, a current entry is the better place to start.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet