Analysis · New Pokémon Snap

New Pokémon Snap's living islands outshine its repeat-heavy grind

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A living world, seen on a lot of repeat runs

The best thing critics said about New Pokémon Snap is that its world feels alive. The Telegraph's Jack Rear called it "beautifully designed" and said the franchise had never felt more alive. The worst thing they said is that you see that world over and over until the charm wears off. TechRadar's Adam Vjestica found that repeat runs of the same courses made the game feel "laborious", and GameRevolution's Paul Tamburro called its boss fights the clearest sign of "tedious padding".

Both camps are describing the same design. You ride a hovering pod called the NEO-ONE along a fixed path through the islands of the Lental region, take up to 72 photos per run, then return to Professor Mirror's lab to have them graded. Good photos earn Expedition Points, which raise an area's Research Level. Higher levels open new versions of a course, where new Pokémon appear or familiar ones behave differently. Some critics saw that loop as a reason to look closer. Others saw it as a reason to sigh.

The courses are the reason to come

Praise for the environments came close to unanimous. Critics pointed to the detail in the jungles, deserts, reefs and caves, and to how many species you can photograph: 214 at launch, rising to 234 with the 2.0.0 update, drawn from the first eight generations of the series. Game Informer's Brian Shea liked that each course spread its Pokémon out so he never felt swamped. He singled out an encounter between Wingull and Finneon that made him want to replay the level.

The new day and night versions of courses drew specific credit. GameSpot's Jenae Sitzes heard the daytime runs as busy and the night runs as calm, and called the variants a "dynamic addition". IGN's Rebekah Valentine thought the game was at its best when lesser-known Pokémon got the spotlight, and said those moments made her want to complete the Photodex.

The mood counts too. Paste, Inverse and Jeuxvideo.com all described something gentle, close to zen. Inverse's Matt Wille made a practical point: because there isn't much heavy progression to keep track of, it's easy to pick back up after weeks away.

The camera tools earn their keep

Critics rated the photography itself highly. Destructoid's Eric Van Allen called it "incredibly fun" and suggested adjusting the camera sensitivity. Each photo is scored on composition, distance and whether the Pokémon faces the lens, then rated bronze, silver, gold or platinum, so every shot has a clear target.

  • Re-Snap lets you change zoom, brightness and blur after grading, and add filters, frames and stickers. RPGFan's Niki Fakhoori called it phenomenal for rescuing photos that would otherwise be ruined.
  • Gyro aiming beat the analog stick in the eyes of Shacknews and Nintendo World Report. Nintendo World Report called it a "natural fit".
  • Accessibility got a nod from Nintendo Life's Jon Cartwright for the range of control options.
  • Online sharing through Nintendo Switch Online lets other players award medals to photos they like, which can get those photos featured in the game.

Polygon's Michael McWhertor described it as a game made for the "Instagram and Snapchat generation".

Where the progression drags

The split comes down to how often the game sends you back. The Washington Post's Shannon Liao felt it leaned too heavily on replaying levels as it went on. RPG Site's James Galizio went further and objected that the option to speed up the NEO-ONE comes only near the end, long after the grind where it would have helped most.

Unclear direction is the second problem. Some critics found the hints too vague. McWhertor liked that LenTalk requests give you reasons to revisit courses and reward you with cosmetics. But some requests were explained so poorly that he took the wrong photo and had to work it out by trial and error.

The game has defenders here too. EGM's Michael Goroff said the structure pushed players to hunt for better vantage points, and Eurogamer's Lynn Lottie thought Research Levels kept the repetition in check. Sitzes credited them with a strong postgame. The boss battles split critics the same way. Tamburro found them sluggish, while Valentine liked their "careful timing" and clever puzzle-solving, even though Xerneas struck her as an odd choice for the final boss.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet