New Super Mario Bros. U is a couch co-op crowd-pleaser that plays it safe
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Built for families on one couch
This game is for groups. Up to four players each take a controller and play as Mario, Luigi, Yellow Toad and Blue Toad. A fifth player can hold the Wii U GamePad and use Boost Mode to help from outside the action, placing blocks for others to stand on or stunning enemies by holding a finger on them. GamesMaster summed up the appeal as "a great excuse for families to gather round the TV."
It's also for players who grew up on side-scrolling Mario. The goal hasn't changed: get to the flag at the end of each level and avoid enemies and hazards along the way. It's a direct follow-up to New Super Mario Bros. Wii and keeps that game's co-op multiplayer.
Solo players aren't left out. The game runs on Wii U Pro Controllers or Wii Remotes, and with Off-TV Play the whole game fits on the GamePad screen, so the TV is free for someone else.
Where it delivers: levels, challenge and new toys
Critics were most impressed by the level design. Game Informer called it the best game in the New Super Mario Bros. series and pointed to "some of the most creative NSMB levels" Nintendo had built. IGN put it "close to" the best 2D Mario games and praised its balanced difficulty.
A few additions give those levels more variety:
- The flying squirrel suit lets you glide over long gaps, drift slowly down tall shafts and cling to walls.
- Baby Yoshis can be carried, and each color does something different. One inflates in midair, and another lights up dark areas.
- One big connected map holds every world. Some levels have more than one exit, and those exits open different routes.
- Nabbit, a new thief character, steals items from Red Toad and hands over items when you catch him.
There's plenty to do after the main game. Challenge Mode adds conditions like short timers, and IGN singled it out as a highlight. Boost Rush puts you on an auto-scrolling stage that speeds up as you collect coins. Coin Battle returns, and the GamePad player can now decide where coins and Star Coins go.
Where it falls short: the formula shows its age
The most common complaint is that the game is too familiar. Giant Bomb said everything about it was exciting "except the game itself," and called it well made but "kind of flatly uninteresting." In its view, the series' by-the-numbers design made the word "New" in the title sound ironic.
Critics also disagreed about how it looks. It was the first Super Mario game in high definition, and many reviewers liked the jump. IGN didn't, calling the visuals and music bland. Destructoid felt it had less charm than earlier entries, even with HD as a headline feature. Before release, several outlets made the same point from a technical angle: Eurogamer and The Guardian both said it didn't push the Wii U hardware.
If you've played New Super Mario Bros. Wii a lot, this matters. Many of the new ideas are tweaks to what came before, not a fresh direction.
What the scores say
An aggregate of 10 critic reviews puts the game at 88/100, and the critic average worked out from that is 8.8. That's a strong result, but the written reviews explain why the number isn't higher. Critics praised how well the game is built while asking for more invention.
A polished, generous platformer that rarely takes a risk.
The Super Guide helps players who get stuck. If you fail a level several times in a row, it offers to take over and move your character through the stage. That keeps younger players moving and fits the family focus. The Miiverse comment feature it launched with is gone, so that part of the original package can't be used anymore.
Sources
- Wikipedia: New Super Mario Bros. U en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q1506526 wikidata.org