Analysis · The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion

Oblivion lets you go anywhere in Cyrodiil, and critics forgave its seams for it

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

One idea: go anywhere, whenever you like

Oblivion is built on freedom. You arrive in the province of Cyrodiil, and apart from areas tied to specific quests, you can travel anywhere at any time. X-Play's Jason D'Aprile said the series had always been known for its size and "freedom of choice", and that this entry takes that idea and runs with it.

The main story has you stopping a cult called the Mythic Dawn from opening gates to a demonic world called Oblivion. The game doesn't push you to deal with it quickly. GameZone's staff noted that players can spend a long time leveling up, doing side quests and shaping their character before they ever start the main quest. The game also never ends, so you can keep playing after the main quest is done.

Fast travel supports the same idea. The main cities are on the map from the start, and every new place you visit becomes a point you can jump back to instantly.

Your character grows from what you actually do

The skill system follows the same principle. You pick one of ten races, each with its own natural abilities, and choose seven of the 21 skills as major skills. Those skills improve as you use them. Every 10 points gained across your major skills earns a level and a chance to raise broader attributes such as speed and endurance.

  • Combat covers armor and heavy weapons like blades, axes, maces and hammers.
  • Magic covers healing, summoning, damage and spells that work on other people's minds.
  • Stealth covers lockpicking, haggling, persuasion, archery and sneak attacks.

Many skills cross categories, and new abilities appear at 25, 50, 75 and 100 points in a skill. You can play in first or third person and change the difficulty at any time. GamesTM's editors credited this "ease of play" with pulling in players well beyond the hardcore role-playing crowd.

Why critics called the world the star

Reviewers kept coming back to the graphics, the size of the world, and NPCs who follow daily schedules. GameSpot's Greg Kasavin rated Morrowind among the best role-playing games he'd seen in years and called Oblivion "hands-down better". He argued that even people with no interest in role-playing games would find it hard to resist.

Eurogamer's Kristan Reed said it fuses role-playing, adventure and action ideas into a "relentlessly immersive" whole.

Scott Tobias of The A.V. Club tied the appeal to discovery, since each environment looks different from the last and asks for a different response. IGN's Charles Onyett praised the storytelling and the menus. A wide, varied world is exactly what a game about freedom needs, and critics said this one delivered it.

Where the freedom shows its seams

The sharpest criticism goes straight at the core idea. Onyett noted that enemies scale with the player's level rather than with combat skill or allies. If the world levels up alongside you, the payoff for exploring and growing stronger gets thinner. He also flagged imprecise combat.

Other complaints came down to polish:

  • GameSpy's Justin Speer criticized long loading times and "disruptive loading stutters" while crossing the world, plus floating objects and lip-sync that drifts out of time with speech.
  • 1UP.com's Patrick Joynt found it "more jarring" when an NPC gives a custom line, such as a guard's warning, and then drops back to cheerful stock dialogue.
  • GameRevolution's Duke Ferris heard voices repeat, though he called most of the voice work high quality.

Onyett's bottom line was that none of this held the game back from being enjoyable, with enough content to keep players returning.

The scores and awards leave little doubt

The critic aggregates are 94/100 for the Windows version and 91/100 across 12 reviews. The critic average of 9.3, calculated from those critic aggregates, matches them. In 2006 Oblivion won Game of the Year at both the G-Phoria Video Game Awards and the Spike TV Video Game Awards. The Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences named it Role-Playing Game of the Year and Computer Game of the Year. In 2007, PC Gamer ranked it first on its list of the top 100 games of all time.

The awards also recognized the voice cast and music. Patrick Stewart's performance as Uriel Septim won a Spike TV award, and Jeremy Soule's score won the inaugural MTV Video Music Award for Best Original Score.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet