Obsidian's Old Republic sequel keeps the combat and darkens the story
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A new studio inherits a hit
Star Wars Knights of the Old Republic II: The Sith Lords is the second game in the series and the first made by Obsidian Entertainment. BioWare made the original, so this was a new studio following up another studio's success. It reached the Xbox on December 6, 2004, and Microsoft Windows on February 8, 2005. Later versions came out for macOS, Linux, Android, iOS and Nintendo Switch.
IGN pointed out how much pressure comes with following an award-winning game made by someone else, and concluded that Obsidian delivered. The setting stays the same: the Star Wars galaxy 4,000 years before The Phantom Menace, with every fight and dialogue check still running on the d20 System. Obsidian's choice was clear. Keep the systems that worked and put the effort into the story.
The combat barely changed, and critics mostly approved
Fights still play out in real time from a third-person view, and you can pause to queue orders. You still bring up to two party members along, and both Pazaak (a card game) and swoop bike racing are back. GamePro said the sequel keeps the series' habit of not fixing what isn't broken. GameZone agreed and called the unchanged combat a good thing, since the original's was already fun.
The changes are in the details:
- 30 new Force powers to build around.
- New lightsaber forms, each suited to a different situation, such as fighting enemies with blasters.
- Prestige classes that push a Jedi toward lightsaber skill or Force power.
- A cleaner interface with two weapon sets you can switch between.
GameSpot noted that the balance was off in both games but argued that this keeps fights unpredictable. Critics disagreed about the party AI: IGN praised it for letting you control only the main character, while GameSpy's reviewer hit AI problems that weren't in the first game.
The writing is where Obsidian pulled ahead
This is where critics agreed the sequel was better than the original. GameSpy compared it to The Empire Strikes Back as the best story in the series and called it the best game story since Planescape: Torment. 1UP.com said the plot holds together better, the dialogue is edgier and the moral choices count for more. Eurogamer described the plot as "far more grey" and found the planets better developed and paced.
Computer Gaming World: your choices on the light or dark path are "more ambiguous, with more unexpected consequences."
The new influence system ties all of this to your companions. Actions that impress them raise your influence. With enough of it, they back you no matter what, and you can pull them toward the light or dark side or even train some of them in the Force. With too little, they can turn on you. GameSpy named Kreia the best video game character of 2005, and GameSpot made her a runner-up for Best New Character.
What a rushed deadline left behind
The same reviews that praised the story were hard on how unfinished the game felt. Players reported pathfinding bugs. 1UP.com said the party "still had a tendency to warp and skip around the map" and blamed the sequel for repeating the first game's technical problems. GameSpy called the bugs "hard to forgive" and, in a separate piece, described the game as incomplete because of its rushed deadline.
The visuals were criticized too. GameSpot called them "lackluster". GameSpy called them "a little dated" and "half-baked", noting they looked just like the first game's. GameZone said they didn't hold up against most big releases of the time. The sound got a split verdict: GameSpy praised the music as "excellent" but noted some reused tracks and more weak voice acting, while GameZone called the voice work "top-notch".
Scores reflect the mix. On Metacritic, the PC version averages 85/100 and the Xbox version 86/100. Aggregates dated July 26, 2022 come in lower, at 77/100 and 67%. Combined, the critic scores give the game a critic average of 7.9.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Star Wars Knights of the Old Republic II: The Sith Lords en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q74669 wikidata.org