Analysis · BoxBoy!

One square hero and a chain of boxes carry a long, clever 3DS puzzler

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Every puzzle starts with a box you make yourself

The whole game rests on one move. Qbby, a square-shaped hero, can push out a chain of boxes from his body, one at a time, up to a limit that changes from stage to stage. What you do with that chain decides whether you get across a room.

Detach the chain and it becomes an object to push into place: a bridge over a bottomless pit, or a staircase up to a ledge. Keep it attached and it works as a shield against hazards like deadly lasers, or as a grappling line that hooks a ledge so Qbby can pull himself up by retracting through the boxes. There's one catch that shapes every solution: making a new chain erases the old one. So the puzzles are less about having boxes than about deciding when to give one up.

GameSpot's Justin Haywald praised how intelligently the stages use this box mechanic, and called the later puzzles "ingenious".

A slow start, then the puzzles bite

Critics kept running into the same problem early on. The first stages are basic enough that several reviewers said the game made a weak first impression. Haywald went as far as calling the early simplicity "almost off-putting".

The difficulty does arrive. IGN's Jose Otero singled out the level design and the challenge of the later stages. USgamer's Bob Mackey made the case for how the game handles that challenge: levels are short and checkpoints are frequent, so a failed idea costs seconds, not a full restart. In his view, that lets you test solutions quickly and strips out the frustration common to block-based puzzle games without making them easier. Otero also credited the generous checkpoints for helping during the hardest puzzles.

If the opening worlds feel too easy, keep going. The critics who found the start thin were the same ones praising the later stages.

Worlds built around one new idea each

Stages are grouped into worlds, and each world adds one theme. One brings in lasers, another adds cranes that carry Qbby around. That structure gives the game a clear rhythm, and Eurogamer's Christian Donlan and Game Informer's Kyle Hilliard both liked its pacing. Donlan said splitting puzzles into short levels kept things fun.

Not everyone agreed. Nintendo Life's Jon Wahlgren felt the game spent too long teaching new mechanics and left too little room to explore or experiment, so it felt restricted. That's a fair warning for anyone who wants open-ended sandboxes rather than a guided series of puzzles with intended answers.

The story is slight. Qbby meets two other characters, Qucy and Qudy, after certain worlds, and that's about it.

A Game Boy look that split reviewers

The game is drawn in plain black and white, a style some writers compared to Game Boy titles. The reaction was mixed: some critics called it "charming" and "stylish", others found it "sterile". Where they did agree was on the animation and character design. The expressive movement and cute designs were well received, which gives a simple square a surprising amount of personality.

Far more game than the price suggests

Donlan was surprised by how long the game runs and how much variety it pulls from such a simple premise. Hilliard said its low price and well-designed puzzles made it entirely worth playing, and VentureBeat's Gavin Greene also pointed to the amount of content for an inexpensive game.

There's a reason to return to finished stages, too:

  • Clearing stages earns medals you can spend on challenge stages, music and costumes for Qbby.
  • Each stage hides crowns that award extra medals, but only if you collect them before using a set number of boxes.
  • Play Coins from the Nintendo 3DS can buy hints when a puzzle has you stuck.

The crown limit is the smartest of these. It turns a solved stage into a tighter puzzle that asks for the efficient answer, not just any answer. Critics landed at 79/100 on Metacritic from 35 reviews, and the critic average is 7.9.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet