Analysis · Ori and the Will of the Wisps

Ori and the Will of the Wisps proves its maker can do it twice

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A sequel built to show the first game wasn't a fluke

Critics judged Ori and the Will of the Wisps on one question: could Moon Studios match Ori and the Blind Forest and then go further? OpenCritic's consensus says it did, and that the studio "isn't just a one hit wonder." On OpenCritic, 98% of critics recommended it. Metacritic classed it as "universal acclaim" on every platform except PC, where reviews were "generally favorable."

Michael Goroff of Electronic Gaming Monthly described the plan plainly. The sequel refines the first game's mechanics, expands the world and adds new moves and ideas. Each part of the game can be measured against that plan. Where it changed the most, critics also disagreed the most.

The movement is where the polish shows

At its core this is a 2D Metroidvania. As Ori, a white guardian spirit, you jump, climb, glide and swim through the new region of Niwen. Fresh abilities open up parts of the map you couldn't reach before. Game Informer's Andrew Reiner said the platforming "soars" and that the game "makes the player feel clever." Destructoid's Chris Carter singled out the "dramatic chase sequences."

GamesRadar+'s Austin Wood went furthest and called it one of the best platformers ever made. He still found a few of the abilities weaker than the rest and called the final level "slightly underwhelming."

Movement also drives the new extras:

  • Spirit Trials, races to a goal where you can see other players' best times and routes.
  • Side quests from characters you meet, which pay out items such as Gorlek Ores that expand the hub area.

Combat is the change critics argued about

The biggest overhaul is how Ori fights and grows stronger. The first game's fixed upgrade path is gone. In its place are "shards," modeled on the materia system from Final Fantasy. You buy or find shards and use them to change Ori's stats and attacks. Attacks sit on a radial menu, and orbs that raise health and energy are spread across the map.

Destructoid, Game Informer and GameSpot all praised the combat, and Carter called it an improvement on the predecessor. Not everyone agreed:

PC Gamer's Tyler Wilde liked the platforming and boss fights but said the fighting is "not much fun."

The Guardian's Tola Onanuga found that fighting common enemies "can feel a little tedious" over time. The record suggests the combat is a clear step up from the original, but not the main reason to play.

The art and music won everyone over; the story did not

No part of the game drew more agreement than how it looks and sounds. Onanuga called it "an intoxicating feast for the senses." Wood praised its "breathtaking music," and VideoGamer's Josh Wise said few games of any budget could match its looks. Digital Foundry put it in its top 10 for game graphics in 2020.

The story got a warmer reception from some critics than others. Reiner called it fantastic, and IGN's Brandin Tyrrel called it "affecting." Wise called the plot "thin." Goroff argued that, with so many emotional platformers around, it does little to stand out. The story follows on directly from Blind Forest, and this time Ori travels without the companion Sein.

Year-end lists sided with the fans. Time named it one of the 10 best games of 2020, Digital Foundry ranked it top 3, and Game Informer put it at #5 in its Game of the Year Countdown.

Pick the version with the fixes

The rough edges are mostly technical. Carter noted frame rate problems on Xbox One, and Goroff described performance issues there before the day-one patch. GameSpot's Steve Watts flagged occasional visual bugs. Eight months later, GameSpot's Mike Epstein gave the Xbox Series X version a higher score and said the technical issues that "held back the launch version" had been ironed out.

One change helps on every platform: the game autosaves, so you no longer have to place the "soul links" that Blind Forest used for saving.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet