Other M pairs sharp Wii Remote combat with a story critics couldn't stand
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
One Wii Remote, two very different games
You play Other M with a single Wii Remote, and the way you hold it decides which kind of game you're in. Held sideways, it's a third-person action game. Samus Aran runs, jumps, fires her arm cannon and curls into the morph ball to roll through narrow gaps and drop bombs. The rooms are fully 3D and she isn't locked to a flat plane, but the feel comes from the 2D Metroid games. Point the remote at the screen and the view snaps to first person. There you can look around, lock on and fire missiles, but you can't take a single step.
Many fights depend on that switch. In one kind of encounter, you hold off a swarm of flying enemies in third person, then flip to first person to destroy the points they spawn from. Critics liked the basic setup. GameSpot's Tom McShea called the controls and combat "unique and responsive", and Good Game's Steven O'Donnell said the simple scheme "works so well". Being frozen in place in first person drew the sharpest complaint. GameSpy's Ryan Scott called it a "weird forced handicap", and Game Informer's Phil Kollar was disappointed that you can't move while aiming.
Melee and dodges, but no item drops
Other M is the first Metroid with melee attacks. Well-timed button presses trigger the Sense Move, a dodge, and the Overblast, where Samus jumps onto an enemy and fires a charged shot at point-blank range. Famitsu's writers singled out the Sense Move for praise.
Unlike in other Metroid games, enemies don't drop health or ammo. You refill at Navigation Booths, which also save your progress, or with the Concentration mechanic. Fights stay tense, but you lose the familiar reward for clearing a room.
The weak spot is the enemies themselves. GamesRadar called them "a largely unimpressive collection", and Edge agreed that the truly testing ones only show up near the end.
A straight line through the Bottle Ship
The game takes place on the Bottle Ship, an abandoned space station. Its Main Sector connects to giant spheres that hold a tropical Biosphere, an arctic zone and the lava-filled Pyrosphere. The route is linear, and the map marks your next objective. GamesRadar judged it a step back even from Metroid Fusion, which took a similar approach.
The bigger break with the series is how you get upgrades. Samus starts with some gear already built into her suit but agrees not to use it until her former commanding officer, Adam Malkovich, authorizes each piece. You still find Energy Tanks and Missile Tanks around the ship. The core abilities, though, are switched on when Adam says so, not found by exploring.
Critics objected twice over: the system drops the series' tradition of finding items, and as a story beat it struck them as nonsensical and condescending.
Secrets still matter. McShea found hunting for them "very rewarding". The first-person pixel hunts, where you scan the screen for a small detail to move forward, were another sore spot. The A.V. Club's David Wolinsky found them irritating, and Official Nintendo Magazine's Chris Scullion called them the "only truly horrible moments".
Handsome scenes, hard-to-love writing
Critics were kinder about the visuals. IGN's Craig Harris said the graphics didn't match the Prime series but still called it one of the best-looking games on the Wii. The Daily Telegraph's Tom Hoggins called the environments "lush and detailed". Reviewers praised the music as atmospheric and true to the series, though McShea said it sounded more like leftovers from older games than a new score.
The writing is where Other M lost people. You can't skip the cutscenes, and Kollar wrote that they "often run as long as 15 minutes". 1UP.com's Justin Haywald summed up the problem: as the game goes on, you get less of the combat that works and more of the story you don't care about.
Much of the criticism focused on Samus herself. Reviewers objected to her immaturity and her loyalty to Adam. G4TV's Abbie Heppe argued that the game made her seem unable to use her own power unless a man told her to, and said her anxiety attack when she faces Ridley didn't fit how earlier games portrayed her. GamePro's Tae K. Kim disagreed, saying the story turned Samus into "an actual human being". Nintendo Treehouse producer Nate Bihldorff also defended the Ridley scene as a sign of strength, not weakness.
Short, and remembered less fondly than it was reviewed
Other M is short, and reviewers said so. GameTrailers didn't think extras like art galleries gave enough reason to play it again. Beating the game unlocks Theater Mode, a two-hour film that combines every cutscene with gameplay footage to bridge them. That's an odd reward for a game whose cutscenes drew the most criticism.
Its reputation has also slipped over time. At launch, Metacritic reported "generally favorable reviews", and the critic score of 78/100 across eight reviews gives it a critic average of 7.8. Later opinion was harsher: in 2025, Escapist Magazine called it "misguided", and Polygon called it the "black sheep of the series". Critics liked the combat, but many players couldn't forgive the story around it.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Metroid: Other M en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q2005910 wikidata.org