Paper Jam's three-hero battles shine while its crossover story plays it safe
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The fights earn the praise, the crossover doesn't
Critics saved their strongest praise for the battles in Mario & Luigi: Paper Jam. GameSpot's Miguel Concepcion called the combat "worthy of the attention", and IGN's Jared Petty found real depth in it. Their sharpest criticism hit nearly everything around those battles. Petty called the world "colorful but uninspired", and most reviewers felt the meeting of the Mario & Luigi and Paper Mario series never reached its potential.
The numbers show the same split. Paper Jam scored 76/100 on Metacritic, but only 54% of critics on OpenCritic recommended it. Four Famitsu critics gave it a combined 33 out of 40. The critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 7.6. Taken together, the scores describe a well-made game that few reviewers loved.
Three heroes on three buttons make the battles work
Paper Jam is the fifth Mario & Luigi game, and it keeps the series' turn-based structure. The twist is a third party member: Paper Mario joins Mario and Luigi, and each hero has his own button. Attacks hit harder when you press buttons on time, and defending against enemy attacks works the same way. Trio attacks combine all three heroes for extra damage.
Critics agreed this was the high point. Alex Jones at GamesRadar+ said Paper Mario freshened up the fights, especially for series veterans. Concepcion liked how the new paper enemies made each battle feel different. Petty noted that each fight added one new element at a time, so the extra systems never piled up.
The criticism was about how much the fights ask of you, not how well they're made:
- Kyle Hilliard of Game Informer found that a third character made things cumbersome at times, though battles were never unmanageable or unfair.
- Janine Hawkins of Polygon enjoyed the trio attacks but found their button demands often too hard and too dependent on memorization.
Battle Cards add perks in combat, such as extra damage against certain enemies. Hilliard liked that they work as collectibles with a real use, and Conor McMahon of Nintendo Life compared the system favorably to Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door. Some Mario Amiibo figures give extra bonuses. Jones and McMahon both found them effective, and McMahon warned that you'd use them often enough to want them close at hand.
Two of every villain can't save a safe script
The premise is two universes colliding: Mario, Luigi and Paper Mario head for Bowser's Castle to rescue both versions of Princess Peach from both versions of Bowser. The setup is the game's best joke, and critics felt it rarely found a second one.
Petty and McMahon both called the paper counterparts a unique addition that often turned predictable, and both said the story of colliding worlds was never fully explored. Concepcion also felt the crossover went underused. GameSpot praised how the two series' writing styles blended but found no laugh-out-loud moments and blamed AlphaDream for playing the writing too safe. Hilliard found the plot less compelling but enjoyed the scenes where duplicate characters meet, especially how the two Bowser counterparts can't work together.
The game has two of every major character and, by most critics' account, too little to say about it.
Long stretches between the good parts
Outside battle, Paper Jam asks you to explore the Mushroom Kingdom, talk to characters and solve puzzles. Some puzzles need one hero's ability, like Paper Mario slipping through narrow gaps. Concepcion liked how the world invited exploration but saw little reason to bother, since collectibles and items were common. Petty found the areas too close to earlier Mario games and short on landmarks to tell them apart.
Jones thought the main story ran too long and too slow, but credited the minigames and other side activities with breaking it up. Critics were split on those breaks:
- Toad Hunts, where a Lakitu sends you back through old areas to find hidden Paper Toads, kept breaking the story's pacing for Petty. Nintendo Life called them a "fun diversion".
- Papercraft battles, where the trio rides a giant paper figure into an arena against another one, struck Jones as one of the game's weaker parts. Hawkins enjoyed them as one-off moments but found they often dragged into tedious repetition.
Concepcion still saw Paper Jam as a good gateway for newcomers to the series. That matches the record best: a solid combat game with filler around it.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Mario & Luigi: Paper Jam en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q20128243 wikidata.org