Analysis · Path of Exile

Path of Exile buries a brilliant build system under very little guidance

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Critics agreed on the depth and split on the welcome

The sharpest disagreement about Path of Exile isn't over whether its systems are good. Critics broadly praised how it builds on the action RPG formula of the Diablo series, especially Diablo II, and it's often described as that game's spiritual successor. The split is over who those systems are for.

Kyle Hillard of Game Informer said the game hands players a lot with "little direction" and called it "not friendly to newcomers." The awards point the other way. GameSpot named it 2013 PC Game of the Year and IGN called it the best PC role-playing game of 2013. Both sides are describing the same thing: a game that trusts you to work it out yourself.

How much there is to work out

The numbers show why opinions split. Every character choice stacks on top of another:

  • Seven classes (Duelist, Marauder, Ranger, Scion, Shadow, Templar and Witch), each tied to one or two of the three core attributes. The Scion is tied to all three.
  • A shared passive tree of 2,268 skills, where each class starts at a different spot. As of the 3.0 Fall of Oriath release, a non-Scion character could spend at most 123 points, so most of the tree goes unused.
  • Skill gems set into sockets on armor, weapons and some jewellery. They level up alongside the character.
  • Support gems that change those skills, adding extra projectiles, chaining hits or life leech. How many you can use depends on how many linked sockets your gear has.
  • Ascendancy classes, three per class, with up to 8 points to assign out of 12 or 14.

Items are randomly generated with different rarities and sockets, so much of the game is a hunt for gear that fits your plan. Choosing an efficient path through the passive tree is a puzzle of its own. For some players that's the main attraction. For others it's a wall.

A grim world that isn't trying to look nice

The presentation split critics in a smaller way. Destructoid's Patrick Hancock praised a world with a "grimy, grungy" feel that leaves the player slightly uneasy just being in it. IGN's Leif Johnson said it went into "far darker territory" than other action RPGs of its time.

Eurogamer wasn't won over by the graphics and said the game lacked Torchlight 2's sense of style and "Diablo 3's polish." That fits the Mature 17+ rating and the dark fantasy setting. The game is going for dread, not shine, and how much you like that is a matter of taste.

Outside the shared towns, every area is procedurally generated and instanced, so each player or party gets its own map. The design is built for replaying, not for running into strangers.

What the split tells you about who will stick with it

The critic scores sit just above the middle of "good." One aggregate gives 77/100 from five reviews across the PlayStation 5, PlayStation 4, Xbox One and Windows versions. Another gives 82/100 from 13 reviews. The critic average, worked out from those critic figures, is 8.0.

That gap of five points is about what you'd expect from a game that rewards study. Players who enjoy planning a build before spending a single point, reading up on gem combinations and chasing the right item will find years of material here. The Best Evolving Game award at the 16th British Academy Games Awards in 2020 suggests it has kept growing since launch.

If a skill tree with 2,268 nodes sounds exciting, this is your game. If it sounds like homework, Game Informer's warning applies to you.

Being free to play is what settles it. Trying it costs nothing, and the first few areas will tell you which kind of player you are.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet