Payday 2 is a brilliant heist game when the whole crew is human
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
"Phenomenal" with a crew, weak without one
The highest praise came from Eurogamer's Dan Whitehead. He said that when the game's "clunky gear" lines up, the result is "phenomenal": the random chaos of Left 4 Dead mixed with the precision of a hardcore shooter, plus the thrill of being the masked robber in a sharp suit holding off a SWAT team. The sharpest criticism came from almost everyone else. Reviewers broadly faulted the friendly AI, and PC Gamer's Craig Owens said poor stealth mechanics undercut otherwise smart co-op shooting.
These two verdicts don't actually conflict. Payday 2 is a cooperative first-person shooter from Overkill Software, a sequel to 2011's Payday: The Heist, and it's designed around a team of players. The praise is for the game with a human crew. The complaints are mostly about what happens when computer-controlled partners fill the empty seats.
Crime.net turns Washington, D.C. into a job board
Heists come in through Crime.net, a fake website laid over a map of Washington, D.C., where contracts pop up from time to time. You can take an open contract, join one another player has started, or pay for one with money from an offshore account. The jobs range from bank robberies and drug runs to rigging an election and stealing smuggled nuclear warheads.
Some contracts last several days, and each day is its own level with new objectives. If a loud day goes badly, the game can add an escape level where the planned getaway falls through and the crew has to survive the walk to a backup. Seven difficulty levels run from Normal up to Death Sentence, and the higher ones pay more money and experience.
Getting downed is where the team design really shows. A downed player needs a teammate to revive them. Go down too many times without a Doctor Bag and you're taken into custody, and on harder difficulties your teammates have to trade a hostage to get you back. That loop works well with friends talking to each other, and it's exactly where weak AI partners hurt most.
Stealth is the most disputed part of the game
Critics disagreed most about stealth. IGN's Vince Ingenito praised the stealth mechanics along with the co-op play and the sound design. Owens at PC Gamer called the stealth poor. Both reviewers were judging the same set of rules, which are strict:
- stay off camera;
- avoid or quietly kill the guards, but don't kill more than four who carry pagers;
- stop any civilian witness from calling the police.
Pull it off and you earn an experience bonus, and some heists can only be done this way. Fail and the alarm turns the job into a fight. You grab the loot, carry it to a drop-off point and hold out against waves of police. The enemies get tougher as difficulty rises, from D.C. SWAT up through FBI SWAT, GenSec contractors and the "Department of Homeland Surveillance". Special units such as the Shield, the Taser, the near-bulletproof Bulldozer and the hand-to-hand Cloaker give each assault its own problems. The PC and Crimewave editions add more on top, including SWAT van turrets, a medic and Captain Winters, who buffs nearby enemies until the team drives him off.
Deep progression, with the best gear held back
Joystiq's David Hinkle liked the depth of customization, the level progression and the random elements that keep repeat heists from playing out the same way. Owens agreed the systems were smart but objected to what he called the game's "insistence on withholding the best toys". If you enjoy slowly unlocking a loadout, that grind is part of the appeal. If you want the good weapons right away, it's friction.
On presentation, Ingenito wasn't impressed by the graphics, though he still praised the sound.
The safes controversy is part of the record
In October 2015 Overkill added safes holding weapon skins, and some of those skins changed weapon stats. The drills needed to open the safes could only be bought with real money. Fans pushed back hard, and adding drills to the in-game card drops a few days later didn't calm things down. A month later, the Completely Overkill Pack turned out to include a stat-boosting skin, even though it had been promised as purely cosmetic. Overkill added 10 more masks as an apology. In May 2016 Starbreeze Studios bought the rights to the franchise and said future safes would be free to open.
Paid items that change stats in a co-op shooter is the complaint that stuck, more than any review.
The critic scores held up through all of this. Aggregates for every platform land at 77/100 from 11 reviews, with 79/100 for the Windows version and 80/100 in another count of 16. A later aggregate dated September 20, 2016, counting 30 reviews, came in lower at 69/100. The critic average, calculated from those critic aggregates, is 7.6 out of 10. The game has sold over 40 million copies as of January 2023.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Payday 2 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q7156711 wikidata.org