Persona 5 builds a whole school year around hitting enemy weaknesses
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A fight turns on one well-aimed hit
Most of the time in a Persona 5 dungeon goes into hunting for weak points. Combat is turn-based, and each party member carries a weapon plus a Persona, a manifestation of their inner psyche that handles the special attacks. Strike an enemy's weakness and it falls down, and the attacker gets another turn. Knock every enemy down and the fight pauses for a "Hold Up".
That pause is where the game's best ideas sit. From a Hold Up, the party can:
- launch an All-Out Attack, a heavy group strike;
- demand money or items from the cornered Shadows;
- talk one Shadow into joining Joker as a new Persona.
So one run of correct guesses can end a fight, pay for gear or grow the roster. Fights can also start on better terms: the party can ambush enemies instead of walking into them, and stealth lets it skip encounters entirely. The stakes stay simple. If Joker, the player character, is knocked out, the game ends, even if the rest of the party is still standing.
Free afternoons decide how strong the party gets
Around the fighting is a full year of high school in modern-day Tokyo, run on a day-night cycle and weather. Joker goes to class, then chooses how to spend the rest of the day: a part-time job, a leisure activity, or making items for dungeons and battle. Those choices raise his social statistics, and higher stats open up more activities and options.
The heart of the calendar is the Confidant system, an evolution of the Social Links from Persona 3 and Persona 4. Spending time with someone raises their rank. With party members, higher ranks add combat abilities; with other characters, they bring perks such as new equipment or faster experience gains. Some Confidants lead to romance.
This is where the two halves lock together. Each Persona belongs to an arcana tied to a Confidant, and in the Velvet Room Joker can fuse Personas through the "Guillotine" process. The result inherits skills and stats from its parents, and its strength depends on how far the matching Confidant has advanced. An evening spent with a friend is, in effect, a dungeon upgrade.
The dungeons come in two kinds, both inside the Metaverse. Palaces are built for the story, with puzzles solved using Joker's "Third Eye", which highlights objects to interact with and shows how strong enemies are, plus Safe Rooms for saving and fast travel. Mementos is randomly generated and is where quests from Confidants and other characters get done.
Critics praised the look more than the words
Praise was close to unanimous. Metacritic logged "universal acclaim", and Famitsu gave the game a near-perfect score. IGN's Andrew Goldfarb called it "easily one of the deepest JRPGs of the last decade", and PlayStation Official Magazine – UK went with "an unabashed masterpiece". Critics singled out the graphical style and art direction in particular. The critic average, computed from these critic aggregates, is 9.4 out of 10.
The English writing drew the sharpest complaints. Polygon called the localization "aggravatingly mediocre". At Paste, Kenneth Shepard found the game heteronormative and pointed to a "lecherous" gay couple played as a joke. That dialogue was changed in the Western release of Persona 5 Royal, and both Shepard and Polygon's Laura Dale saw the change as at least a minor improvement, while still finding the game broadly uninclusive to LGBTQ identities.
Plan for a long year, or play the longer cut
Length split critics. Writers at The Verge and Wired noted the game may run too long for some players. The structure explains why: Joker lives out a whole school year, one day at a time. For players who want depth, that span is the point, since Confidant ranks, fusion options and social stats all need time to grow.
Then there's the question of which version to pick. Persona 5 Royal is an enhanced release with new content, and it scored even higher with critics than the original. GameSpot's Michael Higham said Royal's added third semester fixes the original's abrupt ending, and IGN's Leana Hafer praised how much more alive its Mementos feels. Royal runs on PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S, Nintendo Switch and Windows; the original is on PlayStation 3 and PlayStation 4 only.
The original is still worth playing on PlayStation 3, where its critic scores match the PlayStation 4 version. Anyone starting fresh on a newer system should go straight to Royal.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Persona 5 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q15225985 wikidata.org