Persona 5 Royal gives the sixth Persona the ending it was missing
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The sixth Persona, released a second time
Persona 5 arrived in 2016 as the sixth installment in the Persona series, which is itself a spin-off of Megami Tensei. Royal is its enhanced version. Atlus released it for PlayStation 4 in Japan on October 31, 2019, and Sega published it worldwide on March 31, 2020. On October 21, 2022 it reached PlayStation 5, Xbox One, Xbox Series X and Series S, Nintendo Switch and Windows.
Critics treated Royal as more than a reissue. Metacritic lists it as receiving "universal acclaim" with a higher score than the original, and it's tied with The Last of Us Remastered as the third-highest-rated PlayStation 4 game on that site. Critic aggregates sit at 95/100 across all six platforms, with 94/100 and 98% from 164 reviews. The critic average of 9.5 is calculated from those numbers.
The third semester is the change that matters most
GameSpot's Michael Higham praised Royal's new music, its new characters and the added third semester. He argued that the extra stretch of story fixes one of the original game's real shortcomings: it ended abruptly. That's the strongest case for Royal, because pacing at the very end is a structural problem that no amount of polish elsewhere could repair.
The other big change is to Mementos, the randomly generated dungeon where the party takes on quests from Confidants and other characters. In the original it was the filler between story dungeons. IGN's Leana Hafer called Royal "a living master class" in improving a game that was already great, and said the work on Mementos counts as "a massive improvement by itself." Famitsu also praised the newer elements.
What stayed the same: a school year that feeds the fights
The core loop hasn't changed. You play Joker, a high school student living through one year in modern Tokyo, on a day-night calendar with weather and scripted events. The game splits that year between two halves:
- Daily life. School, part-time jobs, leisure and crafting raise Joker's social stats, and those stats open up new activities and conversation options.
- Confidants. These relationships grew out of the Social Link system from Persona 3 and Persona 4. Ranking up a party member's Confidant gives them combat abilities, other Confidants grant perks such as new equipment or faster experience gains, and some lead to romance.
- Palaces and Mementos. Story dungeons and a random one, played with stealth, ambushes and the Third Eye ability, which highlights objects you can interact with and shows how strong enemies are.
- Turn-based battles. Hitting a weakness knocks an enemy down and earns another turn. Knock down every enemy and you trigger a Hold Up, which lets you launch an All-Out Attack, demand money or items, or talk a Shadow into becoming one of your Personas.
These systems all feed each other, which is why the formula didn't need changing. An evening spent with a friend makes your Persona fusions in the Velvet Room stronger, because a fused Persona's power depends on how far its linked Confidant has advanced. Critics praised the style and art direction just as much as the play.
The old complaints were only partly fixed
Critics had two main objections to the original. Polygon called its English localization "aggravatingly mediocre." Writing for Paste, Kenneth Shepard found the game heteronormative and pointed to a "lecherous" gay couple played as a joke.
Royal's Western release changed the dialogue in those scenes, and its localization team pushed for that change. Shepard and Polygon's Laura Dale both judged it at least a minor improvement, but they still found the game broadly uninclusive of LGBTQ identities. Royal adjusted those specific scenes. It didn't rethink how the game handles LGBTQ characters.
Length is the other caveat. Writers at The Verge and Wired noted that Persona 5 may be too long for some players, and Royal makes it longer by adding a whole semester. If the original's run time already sounded like a lot, the expanded game won't change your mind.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Persona 5 Royal en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q63385672 wikidata.org