Persona Q puts two Persona casts inside a dungeon crawler you map by hand
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A Persona crossover built on another series' bones
Persona Q: Shadow of the Labyrinth is a 2014 spin-off for the Nintendo 3DS that brings the casts of Persona 3 and Persona 4 into one game. It belongs to the Persona series, which is part of the larger Megami Tensei franchise. Instead of copying the main games, Atlus built it around the first-person dungeon crawling of Etrian Odyssey, another series from the same studio, P-Studio.
So it plays less like a new numbered Persona and more like two of the developer's lines meeting halfway. Several critics said the blend worked. Most of their complaints also come from that mix, especially the backtracking that maze crawlers ask for.
The big change is a map you draw yourself
Exploration happens in first person, through large maze-like floors connected by stairs. You draw the map yourself, sketching in walls and dropping icons for landmarks so return trips are easier. If that sounds like a chore, an auto-mapping mode does it for you. A counter tracks the percentage of tiles you've stepped on, and reaching 100 percent makes a treasure chest appear on that floor.
Danger comes in two forms. Shadows appear at random. FOEs are much tougher enemies that move around the map as you move, so you have to plan your route to get past them.
Critics responded to the mapping more than to anything else in the game:
- Polygon's Megan Farokhmanesh called map drawing "fun, personal and rewarding".
- Destructoid's Kyle MacGregor enjoyed drawing maps and making notes but criticized how much time backtracking wastes.
- IGN's Meghan Sullivan also found it tedious at times, though she enjoyed the exploration and puzzles.
- Game Informer's Kimberly Wallace said some players might find the drawing tedious, but she liked working out the right path. She also said giving each labyrinth its own theme was an improvement over Etrian Odyssey.
What it kept: Personas, fusion and a fight you can break open
Between dives, a high school serves as the hub. There you heal the party, sell materials that enemies drop to buy new equipment, and fuse Personas into stronger versions. Anyone who has played Persona 3 or Persona 4 will know this loop.
Battles are turn-based, and each character can equip a sub-persona alongside their main one. Hitting a weakness or landing a critical hit puts a character into "boost", which temporarily removes the health and magic costs of their skills. The more characters you have boosted, the better your chances of stronger attacks and combined moves. IGN's Sullivan praised how much strategy this system draws from Etrian Odyssey, pointing to party arrangement, the extra Personas and leader skills.
Your party can include characters from both games, and who you bring changes some of the dialogue and story events. That gives fans a reason to try different lineups.
Lighter writing, slower setup
MacGregor found the writing more playful than in past Persona titles. Wallace, Farokhmanesh and Sullivan also enjoyed the banter between the two casts.
The new characters, Rei and Zen, got a cooler reception. Sullivan said the game focuses on them but takes too long to explain who they are. Farokhmanesh thought the cast as a whole wasn't as strong as in earlier Persona games, though she still liked them. The story's strength is the crossover cast, not the two newcomers.
Presentation earned the most consistent praise
Critics agreed most on the sound and look. Famitsu liked both the visuals and the sound. MacGregor called the music "stellar" and counted some of the new tracks among his favorites in the series. Sullivan called the mix of old and new songs "fantastic". Wallace said the updated character designs help the game stand out from earlier Persona titles.
The game also picked up honors. Slant Magazine named it Game of the Year, and Samantha Nelson of The A.V. Club listed it among her favorite games of 2014. Metacritic reports "generally favorable reviews" based on 56 critics, and its critic average, calculated from critic aggregates, is 8.5 out of 10. Atlus followed it with Persona Q2: New Cinema Labyrinth, which added the Persona 5 cast.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Persona Q: Shadow of the Labyrinth en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q15225786 wikidata.org