Analysis · Pikmin 4

Pikmin 4 makes a tiny captain and a big dog feel like a small army

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A tiny captain who works through a crowd

Pikmin 4 rests on one idea: you are tiny, and you get things done only by directing dozens of even tinier helpers. Your captain leads squads of Pikmin to explore, fight, haul treasure and solve puzzles. Polygon's Emily Price felt the game frames its world so that ordinary objects seem "wonderous". The camera can now sit much closer to the ground than in earlier entries, which adds to that sense of scale.

Each species is a different tool. Red Pikmin can't be hurt by fire, Blue Pikmin walk underwater, and Winged Pikmin lift objects and float over hazards. Two new types join them. Ice Pikmin can't be frozen and can freeze enemies and water, while Glow Pikmin work at night. Bulbmin and Mushroom Pikmin are gone, but every other type from past games returns.

Critics bought into the idea. Metacritic lists 87/100 from 122 reviews, and OpenCritic reports that 96% of critics recommend it, calling the support "mighty". The critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 8.8 out of 10.

Oatchi makes the crowd faster

The biggest addition is Oatchi, a dog-like creature who does a Pikmin's jobs and then some. He can carry objects and attack. He can also bash breakable things, sniff out treasure, and ferry both the captain and the squad across the map and over water. In some spots you control Oatchi directly to solve a puzzle. He gains experience while exploring and can be upgraded back at the hub base.

The rest of the new structure pushes the same way: more helpers, moved faster. You start with room for 20 Pikmin, and Flarlic upgrades raise the cap to 100. You can move your landing craft and the Onion to landing sites you've already found, which cuts the walk between a find and the base. Treasures become Sparklium, and Sparklium opens new maps, so every haul visibly moves the game forward.

The missing mini-map undercuts the big squads

A squad of 100 only helps if you can keep track of it, and that is where the one sharp complaint lands. Ars Technica's Kyle Orland liked the relaxed pace but faulted the lack of navigation tools, above all a mini-map. Without one, he kept going back to the pause menu to find and manage separate groups spread across the layered maps.

That criticism hits the core idea directly. Splitting Pikmin into teams is how the game rewards planning, and the interface makes that harder than it should be. Players who like to run several jobs at once will feel it most. Players who keep one squad close will notice it less.

Some forgiveness is built in. A rewind feature lets you undo mistakes or try a section another way. In caves, which first appeared in Pikmin 2, the clock runs at 1/6 speed instead of stopping. You can also change your squad before you go in, so a long cave doesn't punish a bad lineup chosen on the surface.

Night Expeditions put the idea on a clock

Night Expeditions change the usual rhythm. On certain maps you head out after dark with Glow Pikmin. The Verge's Andrew Webster found these timed, focused challenges a "nice change of pace" from the easygoing daytime play, though he couldn't see a story reason for them. They test the same idea under pressure: the same small captain, different helpers and less time for wandering.

The main missions send you after Captain Olimar and later Louie. Castaways you bring back to base hand out side missions, and Practice Mode trains you to defeat enemies. You can also customize your captain's face and uniform colors.

Nintendo Life's PJ O'Reilly praised the level design and graphics, and said the game runs well on the Nintendo Switch in both handheld and docked mode. That matters in a game where you have to read a screen full of small creatures at a glance.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet