Analysis · Hey! Pikmin

Pikmin's first handheld spin-off turns strategy into a gentle side-scroller

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A captain who can't fight, and a crowd that does it for him

Nintendo's first handheld Pikmin takes a series known for real-time strategy and flattens it into a side-scrolling platformer. Captain Olimar can't attack anything on his own. The Pikmin he recruits handle every threat in the game, which makes the small creatures both his only weapon and his only tool.

That idea shapes most of the design. In the other Pikmin games, players choose which Pikmin to bring into a level. Here they don't. They enter a level and work with whichever Pikmin turn up while they explore. Olimar adds his own movement: he can swim, and a jetpack lifts him to new areas. Winged Pikmin can carry him through the air.

The goal is fuel. Olimar collects items containing "sparklium", the fuel his ship runs on. More sparklium buys upgrades to his space suit, such as more jetpack fuel or the ability to take more hits.

The game came out in July 2017 for the Nintendo 3DS, developed by Arzest and published by Nintendo. It was the series' first handheld entry, and it was made as a spin-off rather than a mainline game.

The puzzles mostly ask you to throw

A captain who depends entirely on his crew could support some clever problem-solving. Critics mostly said it doesn't. Their most common complaint about the game was simple puzzles with little depth, especially next to the console games.

Game Informer put it bluntly. Its review said the puzzles usually come down to tossing Pikmin around obstacles, and that the mix of strategy and action ends up stuck between relaxing and boring:

Nintendo's low-impact blend of strategy and action "flounders between relaxing and boring." (Game Informer)

That criticism hits the central idea directly. When players can't pick their Pikmin, the level designer decides which tools they get and roughly how to use them. That keeps things approachable, but it also removes the planning that defines the series. Take the strategy out of a strategy series and the platforming has to carry the game. Reviewers didn't think it could.

Pikmin Park gives the crowd somewhere to go

After each level, every recruited Pikmin moves to Pikmin Park. From there they can be sent out to find more objects that hold sparklium. Colored pellets raise the park's Pikmin count, and each section cleared opens another for them to search.

This is the one place where the series' squad management comes back, even if it's light. The crowd keeps working between levels, and the park's growth gives the sparklium hunt a goal beyond the next suit upgrade. Critics didn't single the park out for praise or blame. It reads as a quiet side activity, not a second game.

Where amiibo support earned the warmest words

The feature critics liked most has nothing to do with the puzzles. The game works with every amiibo released before its launch, and each one gives a bonus in the game. A Pikmin-themed amiibo came out alongside it.

Polygon's Allegra Frank said the game might not be the most exciting one on the 3DS, pointing to Miitopia, but called its amiibo features the most charming in a long time. For players who already own a pile of figures, that adds real value. For everyone else, it adds nothing.

What the scores add up to

The critic record backs up the "mixed" label without much disagreement:

  • OpenCritic: a 70/100 average across 56 reviews, with 38% of critics recommending it
  • Metacritic: "mixed or average"
  • Famitsu: 33 out of 40 from four critics in Japan

The Famitsu score is the warmest of the three. Japanese buyers were cooler: the game sold more than 65,000 units in its first week there and 157,000 by January 2021, which made it the worst-selling Pikmin title in Japan. It carries an Everyone 10+ rating, and its gentle pace suits that age group better than it suits players who come for strategy.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet