Analysis · PlanetSide 2

PlanetSide 2 runs 2,000-player wars for free, and that's the argument

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Critics split over the free-to-play model

Critics agreed that PlanetSide 2's battles are huge. They disagreed about what it costs to enjoy them. The game is free-to-play, and many early reviews counted that as a strength, next to the scale and the graphics. Patrick Hancock of Destructoid saw it the other way. He called it a "wonderful game, hampered" by the free-to-play model.

Hancock's complaint was the grind. You make progress with Certs, a currency earned by killing enemies and capturing objectives, and he said the game doesn't explain its many systems well. Griffin McElroy of Polygon praised the gameplay and scale, but they warned that microtransaction "prices escalate quickly" and that earning a single item with in-game currency could take an "excessive" amount of time.

The paid items are mostly cosmetic and give no direct edge over players who don't pay. So the dispute isn't about paying to win. It's about patience: how long you'll play with the starting gear before the upgrades you want arrive.

The scale is what nearly everyone praised

Each continent covers 64 km2 and holds up to 2,000 players at once. They're split among three factions: the New Conglomerate, the Terran Republic and the Vanu Sovereignty, whose alien style carries into its weapons and vehicles. The factions fight to capture and hold territory, and a faction that locks down a continent earns benefits for all its members.

IGN's Charles Onyett gave it 9/10 and described lines of tanks shelling bases while aircraft "light up the sky." GameSpot's Tyler Hicks wrote that it beat its predecessor "in nearly every regard." Eurogamer's Richard Cobbett called it the best attempt anyone had made to fuse an MMO with a shooter, though "not quite the best of both worlds."

Moment to moment, it uses modern shooter staples: sprinting, iron sights and regenerating shields. An Instant Action option sends you straight to the biggest fight. The six classes run from the Infiltrator, a sniper with a cloaking device, to the MAX, an armored suit that carries a heavy weapon in each hand.

Teamwork is the point, and the game doesn't hand it to you

A squad holds 12 players, and four squads can join into a 48-player platoon. Each squad gets its own voice channel, so leaders can send different groups to different objectives. Squad members can also spawn directly on each other in orbital drop pods.

Craig Pearson of GameSpy liked the "intense" battles but felt the leadership and coordination tools needed work. Reviewing the PlayStation 4 version for Game Informer, Jeff Marchiafava said the game can feel like it "lacks a point." Hancock also criticized the lack of long-term goals.

Taken together, these reviews describe the same gap. The war never ends, and the game gives you no strong reason to care about any single push. An organized squad can supply that reason. A solo player has to find it on their own.

Bugs were the other fault line

Even the most positive reviews flagged problems. Onyett mentioned "some polish issues," and Hicks pointed to population imbalances and "the occasional crash." Jonathan Leack of GameRevolution went further, describing players "teleporting and rubber-banding" and a game that sometimes felt like a "rushed job."

Several reviewers found even more technical bugs in the PlayStation 4 release. GameSpot's Kevin VanOrd still praised the "fantastic massive battles," but said that how much you enjoy them depends on how much you'll forgive its "technical hiccups."

If glitches would spoil a fight for you, a 2,000-player fight won't change your mind.

Who comes out ahead

The critics' disagreements point to a clear audience. The complaints shrink if you want a huge, ongoing war, don't mind earning upgrades slowly instead of buying them, and will join a squad. Cosmetics are optional, and organized play answers the "what's the point" problem.

If you want clear goals, fast progression without spending money, or a polished technical experience, read the cooler reviews closely, because they describe the problems you'll care about. The critic average, computed from critic aggregates, is 7.8 out of 10. But one 2015 aggregate figure sat at 50%, which shows how far opinions spread.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet