Plättchen Twist 'n' Paint buries a clever tile idea under too many rules
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
One critic saw something original, most saw a pileup
The best thing said about Plättchen came from IGN, which scored it 7.4/10. It called the game "pretty entertaining" and said players after something "truly original" would find a "one-of-a-kind offering", as long as they didn't mind a gamble.
The worst came from WiiWare World, which gave it 3/10. That outlet compared playing it to patting your head and rubbing your stomach at once: too many things to track for it to be much fun. It also called the European price "extortionate".
Most critics landed closer to WiiWare World than to IGN. Five reviews were counted for the Wii version, and they averaged 52/100. Both sides agree on one thing: there's a good idea in here. They disagree on whether you can reach it.
A simple goal with a lot stacked on it
Bplus, the Austrian developer, calls Plättchen a "puzzle shooter". The core task is easy to describe. You paint a run of tiles the same color to make them vanish. Special tiles painted in that run fill a point meter, and you have to fill the meter to clear the stage.
Then the layers arrive. Each stage gives you:
- a short time limit to paint your tiles;
- items on the field that slow you down;
- obstacles that can destroy your cursor, which has a little personality of its own;
- gravity that slides tiles across the board;
- tiles that can't be painted at all.
Any one of these could make a puzzle game more interesting. All five at once is where critics said it went wrong.
Why most reviewers lost patience
Eurogamer, at 5/10, put the problem neatly. It described a game buried under an "avalanche of ideas", few of them developed well or tied together. The more interesting parts, it said, were hidden behind rules that were poorly explained and sometimes worked against each other.
Nintendo Power made the same complaint and rated it "Grumble Grumble". It pointed to unclear level goals and to having to shoot down asteroids while you're also matching colored tiles. That pairing sums up the trouble. The game keeps asking you to do two unrelated things at once without telling you which one matters.
When three outlets point to the same flaw in different words, treat it as the game's defining trait, not a matter of taste.
IGN didn't argue that the game was simple. It called the concepts "strange" and the whole package "very unconventional". Its higher score reads as a reviewer who enjoyed the confusion, not one who didn't notice it.
Twisting the remote, and a party mode for eight
The controls are the most distinctive part. You aim with the Wii Remote's pointer and twist it left and right to switch the paint color. The game also supports the Wii Zapper, and Bplus claimed the Zapper gives some advantages over the other setups.
The single player mode has more than 100 levels, which the developer said could take anywhere from minutes to weeks to perfect. Copycat and Mission modes have to be unlocked first.
Multiplayer is offline only, with room for up to 8 players. A mode built around four sets of DK Bongos was planned, but Nintendo asked for it to be removed. Bplus replaced it with Bomb Rain Party Mode. For a game critics called too busy alone, a crowded party mode is either the right home for the chaos or more of it.
Who gets something out of it
If you want a puzzle game you can settle into, look elsewhere. Clear goals and a fair learning curve are exactly what reviewers said were missing.
If you like oddities, the case is better. Plättchen was the first third party WiiWare title to be announced, and its twist-to-change-color control is something you won't find in other games. Go in expecting to work out the rules yourself, and expect a few stages to feel unfair while you do.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Plättchen Twist 'n' Paint en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q7205918 wikidata.org