Analysis · Pokémon Pokopia

Pokémon Pokopia trades battles for gardening and won the series' best reviews

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Critics only argued about the first few hours

Critics barely disagreed about whether Pokémon Pokopia is good. OpenCritic found that 98% of critics recommended it. Metacritic lists it as the highest-rated Pokémon game on the site. In Japan, four Famitsu critics gave it 39 out of 40, and three of them gave it a perfect 10. The critic average, calculated from those critic aggregates, is 8.9.

The small disagreements were elsewhere. Eurogamer's Lottie Lynn called it strange in the way Pokémon spinoffs often are, partly because the hero is a Ditto pretending to be a human. She also said it starts slow and only gets exciting as its systems pile up. GameSpot's Steve Watts focused on what it gets right. He gave it 9 out of 10 and called it one of the best Pokémon spinoffs ever made.

Those two points, the odd premise and the patient opening, are where players are likely to split too.

You play a Ditto rebuilding a ruined world

You play a Ditto that has turned itself into a human. You can change its skin color, hair color and clothes. The setting is a post-apocalyptic world, and your job is to bring it back to life and help the Pokémon you meet there. You don't fight to do that. You craft and build to make friends with Pokémon, and they teach your Ditto new moves for changing the world around it:

  • growing bushes
  • watering dry plants
  • cutting away debris
  • smashing rocks

Each Pokémon shows up only once you build the right habitat for it, such as grass under a tree or a punching bag next to a bench. They also have their own needs. Hoothoot, for example, likes darkness. The more you build, the more Pokémon arrive, and they start helping you and talking to each other. There are 300 Pokémon in total, drawn from the series' first nine generations. A later update added underwater areas with aquatic Pokémon and new furniture.

Why the slow start still works

Lynn's comment about the slow start makes sense given how the game is built. You learn new moves from the Pokémon you befriend, so you have very few tools at first. Your options grow as your town fills up.

If the opening feels thin, keep going. New moves only come from new friends.

The day and night cycle follows the real-world clock, and that was the feature Lynn liked most. The clock sits in the menu instead of on screen, which she said kept her thinking about what to do next rather than when to do it. She also found that the real-time cycle adds some strategy to growing things. Watts praised the mix of building, exploring and bonding with Pokémon. He argued that it fixes weak spots in Animal Crossing and Dragon Quest Builders by combining their ideas with Pokémon. Lynn also thought the mix of Animal Crossing and Minecraft ideas was a sensible one.

Who will bounce off it

Watts valued Pokopia because it isn't about battles, and that's also the clearest reason some players won't want it. If you come to Pokémon for type matchups and team building, there's nothing like that here. Players who don't like games that run on a real-time clock should also know the day and night cycle is tied to your actual time of day.

Everyone else is well served. It's rated Everyone and PEGI 3, it supports single-player and multiplayer, and it combines a well-liked crafting formula with a cast many players already love. It's only on Nintendo Switch 2, and it was popular enough to become the console's second-best-selling game.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet