Analysis · Pokémon Scarlet

Pokémon Scarlet's open world sets you free, then stumbles under you

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The pitch is freedom of order

Critics agree on what makes Scarlet different: it lets you choose the order. Paldea is an open world where towns and wilderness run together with no borders between them. That's a first for the series. The story splits into three routes, and the goals within each can be done in any order. Even the Gyms, which earlier games handed out in a fixed sequence, can be fought in whatever order you like.

GameSpot's Jake Dekker called that non-linearity the game's "strength." Nintendo Life said it captured the "real magic" of the original Red and Blue.

  • Victory Road: eight Gym badges, then the Elite Four and Top Champion Geeta.
  • Path of Legends: tracking down Titan Pokémon such as Klawf, Bombirdier and Dondozo for Herba Mystica. In Pokémon Scarlet, Great Tusk is also one of the Titan Pokémon. These items give your mount, Koraidon, new moves like higher jumps and wall climbing.
  • Starfall Street: beating a set number of Team Star members against a timer, then each base leader, across five Star Bases.

Once all three routes are finished, a fourth and final route wraps up the main story.

Open order didn't always mean a clear purpose

The open structure also drew the sharpest design complaints. GamesRadar+'s Joel Franey criticized its "aimlessness" and "notable lack of stakes." Polygon's Kenneth Shepard said the game didn't make clear which order its major story beats were meant to come in, and he expected that would leave players confused. GameRevolution's Jason Faulkner went further, calling progression "awkward and semi-linear" despite the open map.

So the main idea splits critics. The freedom is real, but some reviewers felt the sense of direction a fixed path used to give was lost along the way.

The open world is where it breaks

An open world only works if moving through it feels good, and this is where critics were most united. Publications reported graphical glitches and poor performance. They also compared the visuals unfavorably with other Switch games such as Xenoblade Chronicles 3. Eurogamer's Oliver Mackenzie called the games a downgrade from Pokémon Legends: Arceus and "comprehensive technical failures" next to other games on the system.

IGN's Rebekah Valentine enjoyed the open-world style and new features like Tera Raids, but said the technical problems undercut the game's new ideas. The Guardian's Tom Regan found it a fun take on the formula held back by the same issues. Some players asked for refunds soon after launch, and Nintendo granted most of them.

The idea depends on a big world you want to roam, and that world is the part critics most often said was broken.

Battles and story hold up better

Away from the map, critics found more to like. Shepard praised Terastallization for adding strategy to battles, and he praised the writing too. Nintendo Life called the story "wholesome," with "genuinely tender moments." Franey liked the music and the interface improvements.

Some smaller features also fit the open-world idea. Auto Battle lets you send a Pokémon out to beat wild Pokémon without entering a turn-based fight, and you can choose whether to battle Trainers on paths. There are 112 new Pokémon, including the starters Sprigatito, Fuecoco and Quaxly.

Not everything carried over, though. Shepard said many quality-of-life features from Legends: Arceus were removed. In a retrospective for Nintendo World Report, Willem Hilhorst said those cuts and the lack of polish "jam the gears" for casual and returning players alike.

Where the scores settled

Metacritic rated the reviews "mixed or average," which makes Scarlet and Violet the lowest-rated mainline Pokémon games. On OpenCritic, 48% of critics recommended them. The aggregate dated December 20, 2022, stands at 72/100 from 106 reviews, and the Switch and Switch 2 versions each sit at 69/100 from eight reviews. The critic average of 6.9 out of 10 is calculated from those critic scores using a published formula.

Critics reviewed the game at launch. The expansion pass, The Hidden Treasure of Area Zero, came later: The Teal Mask on September 13, 2023, and The Indigo Disk on December 14, 2023. The epilogue, Mochi Mayhem, followed on January 11, 2024. None of those three are covered by the reception above.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet