PopCap's lawn defense game turned a puzzle studio's polish into strategy
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The PopCap game that outsold Bejeweled and Peggle
Before 2009, PopCap Games was best known for Bejeweled and Peggle, two games you could understand in seconds. Plants vs. Zombies kept that clarity and took it into tower defense, a strategy genre. It worked. On May 20, 2009, about two weeks after launch, it was declared the fastest-selling game PopCap had made, and it soon passed both earlier hits as the studio's best seller.
It was also the first game in what became the Plants vs. Zombies series. Aggregate critic scores sit at 87 and 88 out of 100, and the critic average, computed from those critic numbers, is 8.8. It has since been called one of the greatest video games of all time.
A front lawn turned into a grid of lanes
The setup is simple. Your house sits on the left, zombies shamble in from the right along parallel lanes, and you plant defenders on a grid to stop them. Some plants shoot, some explode, some just block, and support plants such as Sunflowers produce sun, the resource you spend on everything else.
The tactical pressure comes from small rules:
- Before each level you choose a limited set of seed packets, so you commit to a plan before you see the waves.
- Each plant recharges after you place it, so you can't spam your best defender.
- Every lane has one single-use lawnmower, pool cleaner or roof cleaner as a last line of defense. Lose it, and the next zombie through ends the level.
The zombies are where the variety lives. The Balloon Zombie floats over your plants until a Cactus pops it, and the Dolphin Rider Zombie jumps over a plant in the pool. Waves get denser as a level goes on, and a flag-holding zombie leads an extra-large wave at the end of each level, often in the middle too.
Easy to learn, and critics argued over how hard it gets
Reviewers agreed the core idea is easy to grasp. They disagreed on whether the game stays easy. GamesRadar+'s Tom Francis said it was casual only in how quickly you understand it, and described spending 30 hours, in effect, gardening. GameSpot's Chris Watters saw it the other way: tower defense veterans sit through a lot of simple, familiar action before the real challenge arrives, and some may give up first. GamePro's Tae Kim never had to restart a level, and Rock Paper Shotgun's John Walker said the difficulty sometimes felt artificial.
Even Watters praised how often new plants arrive, and Eurogamer's Christian Donlan said every zombie type demands a response while each new plant opens a new strategy. That steady drip is the game's real hook. Several critics read the whole Adventure mode as a long tutorial for the extra modes, and Francis argued those modes outweigh the main campaign by the time you finish it.
Charm carries more weight than it looks
The art and sound are a big part of why the game reached so many players. The Escapist's Susan Arendt called the music excellent and the art charming, and Watters singled out animation with a "great sense of personality." Wired's Earnest Cavalli noted that a premise about the undead still leaves "something to laugh about" in every level. IGN's Daemon Hatfield liked how the soundtrack builds as your yard fills with enemies.
The lone dissent on sound came from Walker, who found the in-game music "disappointing" next to the promotional music video.
Which version to pick
The game has been ported widely, and critics treated the ports very differently:
- Xbox 360: praised for adding exclusive Co-op and Versus modes.
- iPad: praised for including Mini-Games and Survival, plus an exclusive mini-game.
- iPhone: faithful to the computer version, but critics missed the cut modes.
- PS Vita: faithful, though critics doubted it added enough for anyone who already owned the game.
- Nintendo DS: added four mini-games and Versus, but critics faulted weaker graphics, an unstable frame rate, a mostly idle top screen and a high price.
The DS version is the one to avoid. It was also the only version that drew "mixed or average" reviews instead of praise.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Plants vs. Zombies (video game) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q379128 wikidata.org