Portia is a slow crafting life that charms and drags in turn
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Slow is the whole point, and the whole problem
Critics kept coming back to one idea: the game moves at its own unhurried pace, and how you feel about that pace decides how you feel about the game. Philippa Warr of PC Gamer put it most clearly. She wrote that by being so slow, Portia manages to do both of these things:
"both repels and appeals" (PC Gamer)
Warr called it a kind of oasis that makes few demands and suits "the right player or the right mood." Most of the other reviews read like variations on her point. What critics loved and what they disliked were often the same thing seen from different sides.
The crafting loop is where the calm pays off
The game asks you to gather resources, combine them in recipes and turn the finished items in for money, rewards and favor with the town. Along the way you get better tools, such as a chainsaw for felling large trees, so harvesting speeds up. The biggest jobs change the town itself, which gives the busywork a visible result.
This is the part of the slow pace that works. Ginny Woo of GameSpot called the crafting system well designed. Miranda Sanchez of IGN found the core gameplay fun. Zoe Delahunty-Light of GamesRadar+ pointed to a real sense of progression. Patience here earns a better tool, a bigger job, or a change in town that wasn't there before.
Sanchez added a catch: each of the game's parts falls short in some way. The loop holds together, but none of its pieces stands out on its own.
Where the slowness turns into waiting
Slow isn't the same as waiting, and several critics said Portia doesn't always know the difference. Alex Fuller of RPGamer called the game "very enjoyable" but too long. He objected that players "have to wait for NPCs to decide to do something" before they can move forward. Rich Meister of Destructoid made the same point, saying the waiting "can get old pretty fast," and called the mining "painfully dull."
Woo raised two more problems at GameSpot:
- The day-night cycle works against the pace of everything else.
- The story's premise never really pays off, and several systems lack meaning.
This is where the core idea breaks down. A slow game holds you when each day ends with something done. Critics found too many days that ended with nothing to do but wait for tomorrow.
A town worth spending time in
The setting is what kept most critics around through the slow stretches. Delahunty-Light praised the NPCs as convincing and the seasonal events as varied. You can befriend, date and marry some of the townsfolk, which gives the time between jobs some purpose. Rebecca Stow of Push Square called it "vibrant, relaxing, and brimming with charm." Meister, for all his complaints, still found the world "bright and full of charm."
There are also dungeons with enemies to fight, which break up the gathering and crafting. Critics said little about the combat, so treat it as a change of pace, not a reason to buy the game.
Rough edges that make a slow game slower
The technical problems hurt this game more than most, because they add even more waiting to a game already built on it. Delahunty-Light faulted the loading times and the lack of voice acting in cutscenes. Sanchez pointed to "annoying audio bugs." Chris Scullion of Nintendo Life only recommended the game once a patch had fixed its long loading times.
The scores reflect all this. Metacritic labels the reception "mixed or average." Aggregate scores sit at 72/100 across the Switch, Xbox One, PlayStation 4 and Windows versions, and at 74/100 from a 70-review count. The critic average, worked out from those critic aggregates, is 7.3. That makes it likable and flawed, not something to avoid.
Sources
- Wikipedia: My Time at Portia en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q61046582 wikidata.org