Analysis · Detroit: Become Human

Quantic Dream's android drama makes choices count but fumbles its themes

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

One critic called it a gold standard, another called it ham-fisted

Critics who loved Detroit: Become Human and critics who didn't were often reacting to different parts of the same game. GamesRadar+'s Andy Hartup called it "the new gold standard" for meaningful choice in games. VideoGamer.com's Colm Ahern found the story "cringey and ham-fisted" and said players wouldn't want to play it more than once. To him, the flowchart was one of its few redeeming features.

Most critics landed closer to Hartup. Metacritic called the reception "generally favorable", OpenCritic counted 71% of critics recommending it, and the aggregate scores run from 79 to 87 out of 100. Those numbers give it a critic average of 8.2 out of 10, calculated from the critic scores. Still, nearly every positive review had a complaint about the writing, so most of the disagreement shows up inside individual reviews rather than between critics.

The branching is the real achievement

You play as three androids: Connor, a police investigator hunting androids that have broken from their programming; Kara, a housekeeper protecting a young girl; and Markus, a caretaker who sets out to free other androids. Any of them can die, and when one does the story continues without them. There's no game over screen.

Your choices come through dialogue and quick time events, and after each chapter a flowchart shows which paths you took and which you missed. You can rewind to earlier points to change a decision.

Critics agreed more on this than on anything else. Electronic Gaming Monthly's Michael Goroff called the combined effect of your decisions the game's "biggest accomplishment". Game Revolution's Paul Tamburro wrote that choices changed the story "drastically", and IGN's Lucy O'Brien found the branching paths "multiple and deep". Hartup offered the one qualification: he loved the consequences but said those moments came only rarely.

Connor carries the story and Markus divides it

Critics praised the performances more consistently than the scripts. Tamburro and O'Brien both singled out Curry, Dechart and Williams, and Tamburro ranked the game among the best-acted around. Destructoid's Chris Carter liked Connor's "calm demeanor", and Game Informer's Kimberley Wallace called the character development the "highlight of the game".

The individual stories got a rougher reception:

  • Markus: Wallace called his the weakest of the three and cited "predictable speeches" and black-and-white choices. GameSpot's Peter Brown found him "remarkably lacking in nuance".
  • Kara: Carter blamed the weakness of her story on Cage's writing.
  • Themes: Brown called the historical parallels "on-the-nose", and Wallace called them "heavy-handed". Carter said the treatment of the Ship of Theseus idea stayed at surface level.
  • Abuse scenes: Carter called the portrayal of abusers "cartoonish", and Wallace found it exploitative.

O'Brien added plot holes and "clumsy" dialogue to the list, though she still described the plot as "big, ambitious fun". Taken together, the reviews describe a cast that's better acted than written.

Playing it means scanning, steering and reacting

The game is played from a third-person view. One stick moves your character, the other interacts with objects, and a trigger scans the room for things you can do. Connor's chapters add some detective work: he scans a scene, reconstructs what happened there and replays it, and the more clues he finds before the timer runs out, the better his chances of getting the outcome right.

Critics were cooler on the controls. Goroff liked them overall but disliked the motion controls, especially during quick time events. Wallace found the motion controls and touchpad "unintuitive" and wanted more variety in what you actually do. Tamburro called the opening act "slow" and "dull" and felt the game leaned on quick time events too often.

The flowchart split critics too. O'Brien praised it. Brown said it was "ultimately detrimental" to immersion and wished he could turn it off.

The look of the game drew almost no complaints. Brown called it "captivating to behold", and Hartup called the character models the most remarkable in games, singling out the eyes.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet