Analysis · Rainbow Moon

Rainbow Moon's dungeon-crawl and tactics hybrid comes with a grinding tax

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Built on one switch: crawl the world, then fight on a grid

Rainbow Moon is built on one idea. Getting around the world borrows heavily from dungeon crawlers, and once you engage enemies, the game switches to the rules of a tactical role-playing game. Every part of the game depends on how well those two halves fit together.

Developer SideQuest Studios made that switch the center of the design, and critics mostly said it works. Reception at launch was generally positive, and the clearest praise was for how complete the mechanics felt. For a hybrid, that's the compliment that counts: reviewers didn't describe two half-built genres bolted together. They described a system that holds up as a whole.

That sets the standard for the rest of the game. A hybrid earns its keep only if exploring makes the fights worth having and the fights make exploring worth doing.

Where the loop turns into a grind

The main complaint comes straight out of the core idea. When a game ties exploration and combat this closely, the easiest way to slow your progress is to make you fight more. Reviewers said some of Rainbow Moon's content forced the player to grind, and that was the criticism they kept coming back to.

In a crawl-then-fight game, pacing decides everything. When the world mostly exists to feed you repeat battles, tactical choices stop feeling like decisions and start feeling like chores.

The record doesn't say exactly where the grinding hits hardest or how long it lasts. It does make clear that this was the central complaint, so treat the game's length as partly made of repetition. Critics praised that length, but some of those hours will go to building up a party rather than moving the story forward.

A 70 average that hides a cooler consensus

A critic aggregate of 15 reviews, dated April 9, 2024, gives Rainbow Moon an average of 70/100, with a much lower 40% on its second measure. The critic average of 7.0 out of 10 is computed from those critic aggregates by a published formula. It isn't a score of our own.

The two numbers point in different directions, and both matter:

  • The 70 says the typical review was favorable, which matches the generally positive reception.
  • The 40% says that approval was not widely shared, which fits a game whose strengths and main weakness both come from the same design choice.
  • Fifteen reviews is a small sample, so one or two harsh verdicts can move either figure.

Read together, they describe a game with a clear audience rather than a crowd-pleaser.

Long, good-looking and made for patient players

Beyond the core loop, critics singled out two more things: the length of the main storyline and the graphics. Both help the hybrid. A long campaign gives the systems room to develop, and appealing visuals make long stretches of exploring easier to sit through.

Rainbow Moon first came out on July 4, 2012, and it was released through the PlayStation Network on PlayStation 3, PlayStation Vita and PlayStation 4, published by Eastasiasoft. It's single-player only and rated Everyone, so younger players who like tactics aren't shut out.

What decides whether it's for you is how you feel about the grind. If raising stats through repeated battles feels satisfying, the complaint critics raised turns into part of the appeal. If you want every fight to move the story along, the same design will wear thin.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet