Analysis · Tom Clancy's Rainbow Six Siege

Rainbow Six Siege rewards planning and punishes teams that don't talk

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Praised as the year's best multiplayer, faulted as a thin package

Eurogamer's Martin Robinson was impressed enough by the multiplayer to suggest that the package could be the year's best multiplayer game. In the same review he asked why Ubisoft sold something with so little content at full price. That split runs through almost every review of Rainbow Six Siege. Critics loved what happens inside a round and were much cooler on everything around it.

Polygon's Arthur Gies made the sharpest case against it. He saw the potential, but felt it was buried under technical annoyances, a frustrating progression system and a lack of content. Metacritic summed up the reviews as "generally favorable", and the critic average, computed from critic aggregates, is 7.9 out of 10.

Each round is a short contest of planning and nerve

The structure is simple. Attackers pick a spawn point, defenders pick theirs, and a 45-second prep phase begins. Attackers steer small wheeled drones through the map to find the objective, the traps and the people guarding them. Defenders build their setup and try to shoot those drones before they give anything away. The clock then runs 3 minutes 30 seconds in casual play and three minutes in ranked.

There is no respawn. A dead player moves to Support Mode and watches through drones and security cameras to call out enemy positions. GameSpot's Scott Butterworth said the one-life rule made every match intense, since even the best player has to think to win. PC Gamer's James Davenport called it a "psychological race" of outwitting the other side, and IGN's Ryan McCaffery found it "tense and riveting".

Destruction is the other half. GamesRadar's Ben Griffin credited breakable walls and floors with adding tactical depth, and Game Revolution's Jonathon Leack liked how the scouting phase pushed players to coordinate. Gies disagreed on that point: objectives don't move around much, so for him the scouting lost its purpose.

Operators give it depth, but only a talking team gets the benefit

At launch the roster came from five counter-terrorism units: the FBI SWAT, the British SAS, the German GSG-9, the Russian Spetsnaz and the French GIGN. Each has four operators split between attack and defense, and each operator has a unique gadget. A generic Recruit trades that gadget for more flexible gear. Destructoid's Chris Carter and Game Informer's Matt Bertz both praised the variety and the fun of finding operators who work well together.

That depth depends on communication. Bertz liked how the tactics got players talking, but warned that teamwork may not happen for players without a headset and microphone. Gies went further and said the game stops being fun when teammates go quiet.

A useful rule of thumb from the reviews: Siege is only as good as the voice channel you're in.

Gunplay, progression and the shop drew the harshest notes

Bertz and Griffin both called the hit detection poor enough to make fights feel unfair. Bertz rated the gunplay "serviceable", and Leack noticed a delay in shooting that slows the pace and steepens the learning curve. Leack still praised the map design, the attention to detail and the sound, which he said can make a match feel like a "great action film".

Progression was a common complaint. Operators are bought with Renown, earned from matches, and Butterworth found it slow. Because two players can't pick the same operator in a match, he often ended up as the Recruit early on. McCaffery called customization the "least interesting" part, and Butterworth said weapon options barely change play.

  • Microtransactions: Griffin, Gies and VideoGamer.com's Steven Burns were annoyed by them. Davenport didn't mind, since they're limited to cosmetics and items that can also be earned with Renown.
  • Matchmaking extras: Bertz missed clan support, and Griffin disliked the random map rotation with no vote.

Solo players get training, not a campaign

There is no campaign, single-player or co-op, and many critics were disappointed. Butterworth argued the multiplayer makes up for it. The offline Situations missions split reviewers. Carter called them one of his "favorite non-campaign additions", and Butterworth saw them as good preparation for online play. Bertz found no reason to replay them, Griffin noted they're short, and McCaffery pointed out that solo practice can't teach team tactics.

Terrorist Hunt, the mode against AI enemies, divided critics too. Carter found it relaxing and Butterworth exhilarating, while Bertz criticized its weak AI and lack of variety. Robinson noted it ran at only 30 frames per second, and Gies found that network issues could affect single-player.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet