Analysis · Ratchet & Clank: All 4 One

Ratchet & Clank goes four-player and splits critics down the middle

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A 4 and an 8.75 for the same game

Few games in this series have pulled critics this far apart. Destructoid gave All 4 One a 4/10, the lowest score in its reception. It argued the game should have been about $15, five hours shorter and a PlayStation Network release, and said it does "a disservice" to the series. Game Informer gave it an 8.75 out of 10 and called it one "for all the fans of co-op platforming."

The rest of the scores sit between those two. IGN gave it an 8/10, GameSpot a 7 out of 10, and Morgan Webb of X-Play a 3 out of 5. Metacritic averaged 55 reviews to 70/100, its "mixed or average" band. A second aggregate counting 40 reviews landed at 71%. The critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 7.1.

The split is really about the format

Earlier Ratchet & Clank games were mostly single-player. All 4 One is built around four-player co-op, with drop-in and drop-out play both online and on one console. Each player takes one of four characters: Ratchet, Clank, Qwark or Doctor Nefarious.

Read the reviews side by side and the disagreement lines up with that change. Destructoid's main complaint was that the game moves too far from what made the series excellent. Game Informer liked it for the same reason, because it's a co-op platformer. Both outlets saw the same design and judged it by different standards.

With three friends who'll stick around, it's closer to the game Game Informer praised. Played alone, it's closer to the one Destructoid panned.

What even the friendlier reviews flagged

The good reviews still had reservations. IGN scored it an 8 but called it a step backwards from A Crack in Time, the previous main entry. So even an outlet that liked it didn't rank it with the series' best.

X-Play praised the variety and the story and said the game would keep fans satisfied until the next one. It also criticized:

  • glitches
  • puzzles that are too easy
  • a tone aimed at younger players than usual

None of those reviews calls the game broken. Read together, they describe a sequel to tide fans over between bigger releases. It's rated Teen and PEGI 12.

Who should pick it up

The critics' split makes it fairly easy to tell who will enjoy All 4 One:

  • Groups of two to four. The game was built for this. Drop-in play means a friend can join or leave without ending the session.
  • Families and younger players. X-Play counted the easy puzzles and lighter tone against the game. For a mixed-age group sharing one PlayStation 3, those same traits can help.
  • Series fans who want more. If you've finished the main games and want more time with these characters, X-Play's "keep fans satisfied" view fits you.

It's a weaker fit for solo players who loved A Crack in Time. IGN's step-backwards comment and Destructoid's departure complaint both point at the same gap. If you want a solo Ratchet & Clank, the main entries are a better place to spend your time.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet