Analysis · The Order: 1886

Ready at Dawn's gorgeous London keeps taking the controller away

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A God of War studio builds a London of its own

Before The Order: 1886, Ready at Dawn made God of War: Ghost of Sparta, a game inside someone else's series. This one, released on February 20, 2015 as a PlayStation 4 exclusive, gave the studio a world of its own. It's an alternate history steampunk London where the Knights of the Round Table hold off half-breeds, such as werewolves and vampires, and fringe groups rebelling against the government. You play Sir Galahad, one of the Knights.

The new setting is the most interesting thing the studio brought, and critics mostly agreed it worked. Their complaints were about the game played inside it. Across the aggregators, scores sit between 62 and 68 out of 100, which Metacritic calls "mixed or average".

The look is what critics remember

Praise for the game comes back again and again to its production values. Daniel Bloodworth at GameTrailers singled out the textures, lighting and facial animation, and argued the look and feel alone was enough reason to play it through once. Brandin Tyrrel at IGN called the atmosphere "fantastic". Play, the most generous outlet in the reception at 8.1/10, praised the recreation of 19th-century London along with the voice acting and dialogue.

The acting held up even among the harsher reviews. Kevin VanOrd at GameSpot didn't like much of the game but said the voice work was "far better than the material deserved." The industry agreed on the craft: the game was nominated at the 19th Annual D.I.C.E. Awards for Outstanding Technical Achievement and for Animation, Art Direction and Sound Design.

What it kept: a cover shooter by the book

Under the new setting, the game sticks to a familiar formula. It's a linear third-person game built mostly around cover-based shooting. Galahad carries rifles, pistols, grenades and crossbows, and he can also fight with melee attacks and silent kills. Collectibles scattered through the levels fill in the lore.

Critics found this part solid but stale. Matt Miller at Game Informer liked the controls and the gunplay, yet wrote that it felt like a long-established template for third-person shooting. Chris Carter at Destructoid called the gunplay "well-built but standard", and IGN's review used the word "generic". The weapons split opinion. IGN said they packed a creative punch, while Play complained they ranged from "borderline useless" to "ludicrously overpowered". David Houghton at GamesRadar also pointed to the small range of enemy types.

What it changed: more film, less control

The bigger change is how often the game takes control away from the player. Quick-time events, where you press the button shown on screen to move on, are a core part of the design. IGN found that nearly every interactive moment came as one of these prompts. GamesRadar was the harshest, calling the habit of turning everything into a QTE "maddening" and saying it killed any sense of control.

Between the fights, critics described long quiet stretches. GameSpot said scenes of guns and werewolves gave way to slow walking and examining objects. Destructoid blamed self-indulgent camera angles and a drift toward a "walking simulator".

A few outlets took the design as a deliberate bet. Game Informer described it as a straightforward cinematic adventure that runs against the trend toward open-world games, and enjoyed the scripted action scenes. Play went further and said a short, explosive cinematic game was the best way to show what the new console could do.

Short, and little reason to go back

Length is the complaint that turns up most. Peter Paras at Game Revolution said the game overstays its welcome even at under 7 hours. IGN saw no reason to replay the campaign, Destructoid noted there's no multiplayer, and Game Informer said the story left too many conflicts and questions unresolved.

Buyers turned up anyway at first. It debuted at No. 1 on the UK retail chart and was the ninth best-selling game of February 2015 in the US. One month after release, its price was permanently cut by 33%. That timing says a lot about how its value was judged: a short, single-player, rated Mature 17+ and PEGI 18 showcase that makes more sense at a low price than at full price.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet