Red Dead Redemption 2 builds a peerless frontier with a few heavy flaws
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
One of the best-reviewed games ever, with one charge that stuck
GamesRadar's David Meikleham said Red Dead Redemption 2 "represents the current pinnacle" of game design. IGN's Luke Reilly called it one of "the greatest games of the modern age." According to Metacritic, it received universal acclaim, and it is among the highest-rated games on the site.
The sharpest criticism was aimed at the game's people, not its systems. Polygon's Chris Plante found its Native American characters insensitive and confusing, and Giant Bomb's Alex Navarro called that portrayal clichéd. It's a real flaw in a game that asks to be judged mainly on its writing.
Neither complaint dented the numbers much. Aggregate scores run from 93% to 95/100, and the critic average, computed from six critic scores, is 9.3 out of 10.
Arthur Morgan carries a story critics argued over
The game is a prequel to Red Dead Redemption, set in a fictionalized United States in 1899. For most of it you play Arthur Morgan, an outlaw in the Van der Linde gang, as the Wild West closes in and government forces and rival gangs chase the gang down. The epilogue hands control to John Marston, the first game's hero.
Most critics were won over. Meikleham called it "perhaps the boldest" big-budget game ever made. The Guardian's Keza MacDonald praised the way its twists and smaller stories feed the main plot. EGM's Nick Plessas found Arthur's path to redemption more moving than John's, partly because Arthur has more to answer for.
The dissent was specific:
- Eurogamer's Martin Robinson found Arthur less compelling than Marston, which left the plot feeling muddled.
- GameSpot's Kallie Plagge found the later story predictable, while accepting that it fit Arthur's arc.
- Several reviewers flagged slow opening hours and a long epilogue.
The supporting cast drew wider agreement. USgamer's Mike Williams wrote that the characters "feel like actual people," and Polygon's Eirik Gumeny praised the blunt, unfiltered depiction of tuberculosis.
The open world is where praise was nearly unanimous
Several critics placed this world among the best in games. Plessas said it pushes the industry forward in both size and detail. Game Informer's Matt Bertz singled out its weather and its ambient sound, along with "the most ambitious ecology" of plants and animals ever seen in games. Meikleham went further and called it the best-looking game of all time.
The detail shows up in the systems, not just the scenery. Shot placement and weapon choice affect the value of a pelt, and a carcass left on your horse will rot, lose value and draw predators. Horses bond with you as you lead, clean and feed them. Strangers ask for help, ambushes break out on the road, and towns hold public executions.
An Honor system tracks how you behave. Helping strangers and sparing duel opponents raises it, which earns store discounts and special outfits. Theft and violence against innocents lower it, which earns more loot. Plagge said the variety and surprises made exploring feel compelling, and critics often pointed to that as the game's main hook.
The realism slows everything down, including you
The same attention to detail that impressed critics also wore on some of them. Some reviewers felt the realism limited what you could do and dragged out routine animations. Others found the controls, button layout and menus inconsistent and confusing. Robinson was frustrated by how little freedom some story missions allow.
Reilly offered a defense: Arthur moves more heavily than the leads in Grand Theft Auto V, but not in a way Reilly found cumbersome, and the close-quarters fights were more exciting for it. Plante found the conversation options limited, though still an improvement over the constant violence of other action games.
If you want a Western that moves fast, this one won't. Critics found its rewards came from slowing down.
It's rated Mature 17+ and PEGI 18, and the violence earns those ratings.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Red Dead Redemption 2 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q27438121 wikidata.org